WATCHMEN - The Complete Motion Comic Trailer
Uploader Comments (highlore3)
Top Comments
-
Movie was very good, but... Come on!!! Better than the graphic novel?!?! They are not even on the same planet, the GN is far more complex, deep, interesting, etc, etc, etc. Gn is way better.
All Comments (146)
-
i hate the voice acting...
-
@H3nrix I get what you say, after all it is your perception regarding the story and it is valid. I better go check the comic to know how good it really is storywise. Though I would still not make a direct comparison :)
-
@Pablowanjedi It's the same story, so the comparison is valid if you are talking about that. As a media, you can still compare. Both of them are graphic, one static and the other with motion and sound (quite a clichéd soundtrack, unfortunately). It is different when you "translate" words to video, but that's not the case here. In any case, I'm not complaining visually. Very well done, here. But as a story, nowhere near the original. Your approach is biased and a bit naive, but thanks still.
-
@H3nrix They're different media, follow different rules, it's not wise to make that kind of comparison, one should judge them sepparately. It;s a very common mistake, that we all seem to make now and then.
-
Why does everyone sound constipated in this?
-
No way is this better than the graphic novel. Alan and Dave crammed in a lot of techniques that could only be done in a comic and would simply never survive the translation to any other medium, which resulted in both the film and the motion comic being no where near as deep.
-
@jrad10x10 I'll take the graphic novel thanks, I tried this motion comic and just couldn't finish it because of the subpar narrator, plus them leaving out whole chunks of the graphic novel like 'A Man On Fifteen Dead Men's Chest' (which gives the whole back story of The 'Tales of The Black Freighter' comics) and 'Under The Hood'
The motion comic just really came up short for me. I had read DC has made Watchmen available for downloading on an E-Book Reader ?!?
That should be..... interesting.
-
I thoroughly enjoyed this collection. I really hope they do more like it for other comics.
-
I really hate their vioces.. Just me.
-
My opinion on arguing 'bout which is better, motion comics or comic books.
(On youtube) /watch?v=BNsrK6P9QvI
If only they hired a woman for female voices, instead o use a man for both male and female. But this motion comic worth be watched.
highlore3 2 years ago 20