Renée Fleming - Lucrezia Borgia - Era desso - La Scala 1998
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (294)
-
Well the applause is louder than the Booing!!!
-
Era Dessa is not in the original score of Lucrezia Borgia. Originally Lucrezia simply collapses over her son's body, and Caballe sings it this way in her first (live) recording. Donizetti added Era Desso to placate the first Lucrezia, who wanted to have a bravura aria to finish. I love this opera and feel that Era Desso is the only weak music in it. Fleming doesn't help matters with her tacky ornaments and wayward sustained high note at the end.
-
Perhaps, it took her 13 years to get it right
-
Eine Zumutung!
-
i don't know what they're trying to say. i saw renee singing borgia live last weekend and she was perfect. her tuns were still veyr clean after 13 years, although not as agile, but her trill was as beautiful as ever. i recorded it and uploaded it on my channel.
-
THESE RUNS ARE NOT SLOPPY -- What are you people talking about!?
-
Oh give me a break, you are a deaf moron. It was HIDEOUS. No place on any operatic stage.
-
Las coloraturas están fuera del tono, no me gustó, horribe el agudo final, innecesrio
-
I don't know, I feel like if most of the runs are sloppy, adding a high G is sort of beating a dead horse.
-
Va beh.... le solite americanate.
Il est vraiment dommage que personne n'ait su conseiller stylistiquement Flemming qui est une des plus belles voix du monde. Ses effets jazzy, ses maniérismes gâchent tout. Elle aurait pu être merveilleuse et elle a été sifflée, ce qui est excessif. A Paris même problème pour Il Pirata, chanté comme Porgy and Bess.
opera75frfr 2 years ago 6
BOOOO TO THE FRICKIN AUDIENCE SHAME ON YOU. The ornament wasn't THAT bad.
CantoSemper49 1 year ago 5