Koshkin - Usher Waltz

i still like JW's interpretation :P

I think this is the best interpretation I've seen in youtube, I'm agree that it's a little fast, but defentetly better than Williams...
I really love this song...
to Favorites!

In which aspects is it better? Can you explain?

Yes, but first than all I want to be clear that this is just my opinion. FOR ME... Williams is one of the best players, I can't deny that, but sometimes I feel he forget to feel the music and just play everything "perfect" I like better this INTERPRETATION (not necesarly the execution) because this guy projects the idea of the song, you know... the Poe's tale... that's why I said it's better =) I will record it later soon and you let me know what you think about it ok?

fair enough. I hate how people try and say how someone is better than the other, with out being able to explain.

don't worry, I hate that too, it's called being a sheep xD =P what do you think about all this?

"feeling the music" is a meaningless expression that amateurs who don't know what they're talking about use. If anything, this guy does about the same amount expressively as Williams, just in a different way.

well, that's your opinion.. I have been studying classical guitar for 10 years with very good professors, including David Mozqueda, "feel the music" is something that I use because that's what I think.. but whatever, you be upset about what I said of JW, either that, or you have a big ego...

I don't think Williams understands the terms rall, rit, meno mosso when playing Usher Waltz!

While I still feel this is the best live performance of this piece, and his studio take is outstanding as well, but does this seem a bit fast to anyone?