The 'Mathematical Proof !!!'.. That JohnLArmstrong does not understand basic Logic.

His video:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3q3g6RytxPg&feature=channel_page
My video on the Trinitarian Deduction; One and the Many: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ez0DDIHDrk&feature=channel_page

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_fallacy

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Christianity
• Trinity
• Jesus Christ
• Apologetics
• Ignorance
• Fallacies
• JohnLArmstrong
• Three Persons
• Catholicism
• One and Many.

[TheEcumenator]

i like the analogy that H2O is water, ice and vapour.

water is not ice

ice is not vapour

and vapour is not water

but all are H2O. Simple

[StewardOfEarth]

Wikipedia has a nice definition if you still don't understand transitivity:

In mathematics, a binary relation R over a set X is transitive if whenever an element a is related to an element b, and b is in turn related to an element c, then a is also related to c.

[estragon9]

John's argument is a logical not a mathematical argument. Yes, it uses a classic fallacy and is therefore, invalid. I'm with you. You then go on to say we know God is ... Huh?. You don't KNOW God is anything. Furthermore the idea of the trinity is silly. Trying to explain it logically is like trying to figure out how many angels would fit on the head of a pin. The foundation of your explanation is divine revelation recorded in a very flawed text. You have no argument at all.

[WizardofCalculus]

Actually, this isn't propositional logic, it's a categorical syllogism (which is formally understood in the context of predicate logic).

[cguevara12]

deistpaladin

[StewardOfEarth]

For the apple example.

Apple implies fruit (notice not biconditional)

Apple implies Red (not biconditional- not even a true statement)

By Venn diagram-not a valid argument.

[StewardOfEarth]

Logic-Transitivity of the biconditional. Premise: A if and only if B B if and only if C Proof: A therefore B C therefore A implies C* C therefore B A therefore C implies A* therefore, A if and only if C I would suggest you look this up in a textbook if you don't understand transitivity.

[bandaidmafia]

Q: Is Jesus a being?

[Tunderf00t]

JohnLArmstrong is a deist idiot

this can be proven without math

LOL

[JJTecumseh87]

i cant find that video

[biggregg5]

Oh...now it is poetic allegory.  Will you guys please quit moving the target for your convenience?...and DP a bigot....please.