Judy Garland vs. Howard Keel - The Harvey Girls - Hayride - Pagan Love Song

In 1946, "Hayride" was recorded by Judy Garland for "The Harvey Girls" but never filmed. Four years later, however, the melody resurfaced with new lyrics as "The House of Singing Bamboo" sung by Howard Keel in "Pagan Love Song".

See which version you prefer! (And see if you can guess who plays the native laundress...) .
.

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• MGM
• hollywood
• musical
• outtake
• yt:quality=high

[JansterBanana]

Definitely prefer Judy's version.

[maxie102]

judy all the way

[SuperJacob1989]

poor Howard, ur good, but u have no chance next to ... whats-her-name?

[Linda69P]

Howard !

[Michele5782]

Rita Moreno.

[FLBoy46]

They're both good, but Judy has a way to mesmerize with ANY song she sings.

[sarakat76]

Judy Garland for ever!

[nickbigd]

With Judy's version, I keep expecting some to jump in and sing "that's howvwe laugh the day away in the merry old land of Oz"!

[QueenVictoriaAVC]

Definitely Howard Keel! He has such a great tone and texture to his voice.

[rileyrossi]

definately Judy

[LassieLo]

Judy all the way! "Then a genie appears..."

[luc535125]

i love judyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy  ♥♥♥♥♥