I agree with you on the singing. But how you worked out that guitar playing, that's just fantastic, just perfect, could you tell me what you did? Is it with a different tuning? And, do you maybe have some simple tabs worked out?
Eerrr... I knew that! But it is a little confusing, I agree. It's just the fact that YOUR COMMENT made me realise that my first one was a bit harsh. I am referring to the creator of this video, but my second thoughts are a response to YOUR comment. You see? I shall try to be a bit clearer next time, thank you for pointing at it ;-)!
OK, OK, I might've exaggerated a bit. I still think your voice sounds a bit too emo. I mean, you sound desperate, which is good. But it's still the wrong kind of despair. I love the guitarplay, though.
Unlike some OTHER people commenting on this video, as a huge Joy Division fan, I really enjoy this. With the way you play it acoustically, which is great by the way, it needs to be sung this way. As long as you get the feeling of someone losing control when singing the song, then its good.
Great. Sung with a lot of emotion but the whole point of the song is that it is done as blank verse. Still 8/10
72jjw 2 years ago
the fall out boy version ...
ThEOnlyMistake123 2 years ago
I agree with you on the singing. But how you worked out that guitar playing, that's just fantastic, just perfect, could you tell me what you did? Is it with a different tuning? And, do you maybe have some simple tabs worked out?
Vincspenc 2 years ago
Huge cover!!!Splendid!
You are very talented with a guitar and that tone of despair/madness is just right!
toutafaitfou 3 years ago
superb..coming from a huge joy division fan.
the whole point of covers is that you put your own twist on it..losers.
owaindk 3 years ago
lol no problem, I didnt mean to sound like an ass :P
JaredNorman 3 years ago
Eerrr... I knew that! But it is a little confusing, I agree. It's just the fact that YOUR COMMENT made me realise that my first one was a bit harsh. I am referring to the creator of this video, but my second thoughts are a response to YOUR comment. You see? I shall try to be a bit clearer next time, thank you for pointing at it ;-)!
FSchouten 3 years ago
Why are u refering to ME as the singer, im not singing this, i didnt make this video, I was only defending what I thought was a good cover.
JaredNorman 3 years ago
OK, OK, I might've exaggerated a bit. I still think your voice sounds a bit too emo. I mean, you sound desperate, which is good. But it's still the wrong kind of despair. I love the guitarplay, though.
FSchouten 3 years ago
Unlike some OTHER people commenting on this video, as a huge Joy Division fan, I really enjoy this. With the way you play it acoustically, which is great by the way, it needs to be sung this way. As long as you get the feeling of someone losing control when singing the song, then its good.
JaredNorman 3 years ago