JOAN BAEZ ~ Amazing Grace ~
Uploader Comments (Scout4Me1)
Top Comments
-
You haven't a clue, youngster. There was a begining. Neither of us were there.
Try being 'learned' by this proclamation.
-
@johnnyjemimah This is called "lining" or "call-and-response." It's in the style of a Negro spiritual. This is how you do it when you don't have a song book or don't know how to read. It is just as it should be. Authentic. Beautiful.
All Comments (31)
-
@Chiczaro I really don't know much. I just read a lot. And listen.
-
thanks for that explanation JB
-
@LittleDragon2000 Thanks, you taught me something. I have heard songs done like this before, and I liked it - but I did not know what I was listening to. Too bad these comments have such limited space. If you knew this, you probably know a lot of interesting things about music.
-
@sayasukaso Great observation. I agree. Listen to her sing "Guantanamera" if you are not already familiar with it.
-
OMG! I've just got goosebumps listening to this & tears in my eyes! I'd give anything to see Joan in concert!!
-
Beautiful voice! This is the real singer... her voice could melting the iceberg!
-
beautiful....as is the singer
-
There was a you tube rendition of Amazing grace by Joan posted about four years ago in a stadium where she sang the song without speaking the words. The stadium crowd stood and you could have heard a pin drop. It gave me chills and I have been looking for it ever since and have yet to find it. All I can tell you about it is that it was in a stadium and was the most beautiful rendition of this song that I evet heard. Hopefully, one of these days we will be priviledged to hear it
-
@johnnyjemimah That's the traditional way of singing hymns, so the average person knows the words, in this case it's so the audience can sing along.
-
Joan's way of singing the song - outlining the song before she sings each line - is the traditional way of singing the songs in the time of John Newton. Especially among Quakers and Shakers.
Thanks Didi !
christophe76382 2 years ago
Merci Christophe!
Scout4Me1 2 years ago