Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (705)
-
@chilipeppers91 That quite depends on what you mean by "basic". I love a lot of bands having less technical resources than JD, Bauhaus, and the like. What I really dislike is the mediocre attitude in bands like Nirvana, and Gn'R as well, I stated it from the very beginning. But then one moron started crying about the "impact" of Nirvana being the most important shit in the world. And man, you can't put JD and Nirvana in the same lot, JD was really something
-
@MechaGojira00 If you hate "basic" songs so much, why are you listening to Joy Division? Most JD songs have one incredibly basic bassline that doesn't change from chorus to verse. This one for example, has 3 notes (counting octaves as one note), and a couple of fills. Same goes for Isolation, Disorder, and Shadowplay. The reason for this is that basic music, e.g. JD, Nirvana, is good and advanced music, e.g. Gn'R, is horrendous.
-
@neonbible08 The problem in here is you not being able to read accurately. When I said that creativity wasn't the "big deal" I was talking about Nirvana. I said it once and I repeat it, both Gn'R and Nirvana had a shitty attitude -even worse was that of Pearl Jam-, but at least Gn'R could record a bunch of songs quite interesting compared to those Nirvana did. You need to start listening to some real music, ok maybe not Gn'R, but neither Nirvana, the most overrated band in history
-
@MechaGojira00 haha you are contradicting yourself, all I need is a guitar and to learn a few cords, but you gloss over the creativity thing-(not that big a deal lol) Pointless arguing over music, people have different opinions, I love Jd, interpol, pixies all alot, among my favorites, but they're not nirvana. Although you may believe the nirvana's music was simple, it resonated, and I don't know how one would listen to nevermind and then in utero and label them boring or a minor act.
-
@neonbible08 No, in any all-time best bands Top 20, neither Gn'R nor Nirvana would appear, but as for JD it'd be quite likely.
-
@neonbible08 Chances are because it's quite too easier to try to be like Nirvana than Gn'R. You just need to learn some chords, purchase a distortion gear, and well of course you need some creativity but let's not exageratte it's not the big deal. On the other hand, I don't see too many newcomers trying to be like King Crimson, maybe because its music it's terribly difficult to even try to play it. According to your POV, Nirvana has more impact than KC, huhuhu!
-
tapping my feet .. twiddling my fingers.. lol
bobbing head... ( i like this )
-
@neonbible08 The "impact"? If by "impact" you mean number of bands who are influenced by you and choose to follow in your footsteps then you are extremely wrong. Just ask bands like The National, Interpol, The Editors and The Killers and hundreds of others where they got their sound from. Joy Division is one of the most influential band of all time, what about Nirvana and grunge? They died the moment Kurt took his own life.
-
you may want to ignore it but when judging anything, sports players, politicians, and yes bands the impact on others is part of it, and who had a bigger impact on music? Who admires GnR or wants to sound or be like them...Then ask the same question for nirvana. I love both jd and pixies as mentioned, but saying nirvana was a minor act in comparison to them, just an idiotic statement. I mean you can't honestly believe that.
-
I don't have to defend Nirvana..in conversations of the best 10 to 20 bands of all time nirvana is in the conversation, GnR is not...Slash being good at guitar, well thats another conversation
I would suck the fart from Ian's car seat.
pootynubbin 4 months ago in playlist danny1 12
@hotrodder725 Kurt Cobain was inspired by Joy Division.
LetThemThangsGo 1 month ago 7