2011-2012 Van Vleck Constitutional Law Moot Court Competition Championship
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Uploaded on Feb 3, 2012
SUMMARY OF THE FACTS
Prentice v. Pitel
Petitioner Graham Detroit Prentice is a political activist who seeks to protect the integrity of the Constitution through a non-profit that Petitioner founded. Following September 11, 2001, Petitioner became increasingly concerned with Islamic extremism and began focusing his organization's efforts on protesting against it. Petitioner had little success until 2004, when several members of Petitioner's organization burned an image of an Islamic holy site during a protest in Washington, DC. Petitioner used the consequent media attention to establish his and his organization's name and message, began organizing such extreme protests as a matter of course, and initiated what he claims is a successful "Sharia Prevention Campaign" in 2006.
Two years later, the United States and 41 other nations entered into the Convention on Religious Tolerance. This treaty was a response to a series of terrorist attacks in retaliation for offensive protests outside of Islamic holy sites, which threatened to lead to more protests and even more violence. The treaty required signatories to criminalize offensive protests outside of Islamic religious sites during prayer hours. After much international pressure, the treaty was ratified and the International Responsibility and Leadership Act (IRLA) was passed by Congress to bring the United States into compliance. The IRLA implements many of the treaty's policies but does not precisely mirror it. Specifically, the IRLA subjects anyone who burns or otherwise destroys a religious artifact immediately outside of a religious site during prayer hours to escalating civil fines.
Petitioner violated the act during a protest on July 5, 2009, when he splashed red paint on copies of the Koran outside of a mosque. Respondent Benjamin Pitel, U.S. Attorney for the District of New Columbia, then sent Petitioner a letter warning him that his next violation would result in an enforcement action. After receiving the letter, Petitioner planned, advertised, and carried out another protest on August 1, 2009, where he burned Korans outside of a mosque in New Columbia during prayer hours. After notification of the violation and some settlement negotiations, Petitioner filed an action seeking to have the IRLA declared unconstitutional as a violation of the First and Tenth Amendments to the Constitution.
I. Whether the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Thirteenth Circuit erred in concluding that the International Responsibility and Leadership Act does not violate the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution?
II. Whether the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Thirteenth Circuit erred in concluding that the International Responsibility and Leadership Act does not violate the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment of the Constitution?
Standard YouTube License
- 2:06:18 سورة البقره كامله بصوت القارئ مشاري العفاسيby MRyaser12 Featured 6,590,211
- 1:41:52 GW Law Forum: Fisher v. University of Texasby discovergw2,115 views
- 1:27:37 2012 - 2013 Van Vleck Moot Court Competition Championshipby discovergw436 views
- 1:02:33 GW's Elliott School Of International Affairs Hosts Former President Of Spainby discovergw608 views
- 48:53 How to Successfully Apply for Prestigious Research Awardsby discovergw125 views
- 1:32:28 2009 McBaine Moot Court Competition Final Roundby UCBerkeleyEvents23,870 views
- 1:27:40 The Fifty-Seventh Annual Beaudry Moot Court Competitionby legaleducation32,959 views
- 1:26:55 2010 Lile Moot Court Competition Final Roundby University of Virginia School of Law18,971 views
- 50:29 International Law?by corbettreport11,434 views
- 1:27:39 2013 William Minor Lile Moot Court Competitionby University of Virginia School of Law894 views
- 1:24:59 Game Over - Kasparov and the machineby ADCHESS49,606 views
- 1:25:49 2012 William Minor Lile Moot Court Competitionby University of Virginia School of Law2,078 views
- 1:22:25 2011 William Minor Lile Moot Court Competition Final Roundby University of Virginia School of Law5,941 views
- 1:00:00 Constitutional Law Class -- Prof. David B. Cruzby USC Gould School of Law35,496 views
- 22:09 Mooting Guide & Skills Video For Law Studentsby bpp22,675 views
- 1:01:42 US Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer: A Presentation on International Lawby UCBerkeleyEvents19,659 views
- 1:23:43 2011 McBaine Moot Court Competition Final Roundby UCBerkeleyEvents10,907 views
- 1:25:48 2009 William Minor Lile Moot Court Competitionby University of Virginia School of Law10,982 views
- 1:22:13 2013 Dean's Cup Moot Court Competition: Final Roundby Duke Law5,329 views
- 2:47:08 Mock trial state finals MHS vs PVPAPCSby Brendon Oneil9,904 views
- Loading more suggestions...