Karan Casey - Johnny I hardly knew ye
Top Comments
All Comments (65)
-
@LifesTooShort52 This song dates from the 1820's whereas "Johnny Comes Marching Home" is from 1863 according to Wiki and they do share basic melodic material.
"The Ants Go Marching One By One" and "The Animals Went in Two by Two" both uses the tune
-
Anybody else notice that it has the same basic tune as 'The Ants Go Marching In'? I'm sensing a connection... Maybe it's just me.
-
This isn't a patriotic song, it's an anti-war song, It's about an Irishman fought for the East Indian company in (what is now) Sri Lanka, not his homeland. And it's from the perspective of a passerby meeting the soldier's wife, so it makes just as much sense for it to be sung by a woman.
-
@einstein1984 In a perfect world there would be no need of war or force of will. However Karen Casey is not singing a salute to war here, she is telling of the after effects of war on those who make it home and more often than not it is the women eg. mothers, wives, sisters and daughters that are left to deal with this. To that end I think Karen Caseys tone voice and tone relay that very nicely. Good wishes. : )
-
@MISFORWHAT war*
-
@einstein1984 Was isn't for anyone?
-
@newsatone Patriotic song like this one always sound betterin a man's voice. War is not for women.
-
2 people dislike this ? Well i spose there is no accounting for taste!
-
@Princeofdeadleaves hehe
-
such sadness an misery within the voice yet its beauty is truly astounding
karan`s voice is made out of wind, love and sun
<3 <3 <3
TheCaerry 1 year ago 39
Very touching, forwards some of the horror that the families of those going to war must have experienced - not to mention the sorrow and pity. It's a really good song.
Nogan 2 years ago 18