Olesya Dudnik - 1989 Worlds EF - Floor Exercise
Top Comments
All Comments (36)
-
I thought we talk gymnastics, not ballet or music presentation..
Dudnik's beautiful execution scored a perfect 10 in the compulsories but this exercise, in comparison with Bontas,Boginskaya,Silivas, was not worth a 10. Of the same opinion were also at least 5 of the 6 judges, who gave it a 9.95.
-
@akimbohr I know that Silivas and Bontas had harder routines but each of these routines satisfies the code and this routine had no visible deductions while Silivas and Bontas had deductions. Im just glad that judges back then knew the difficulty of a routine..but really if they were going for clean gymnastics Dudnik should have gotten a 10 for being perfect in all the moves she presented.
-
This routine scored a 9.95, not enough for the medal. Silivas and Bontas had more difficult routine but Olesia got a perfect 10 in the compulsories (that is why she qualified in the EF over Laschenova). Does anyone have that video ?
-
So artistic~
-
@adventuregirl76 ..well said.
-
@LCAmarkymark Yes you are right. I just hate how gymnastics was VERY subjective in the past. It seemed like the cool routines got the high scores, not the good routines..
-
@chrislindsey14 but the current system puts emphasis on certain moves to complete over innovation...so you get a lot of routines that barely make the cut...while this routine was difficult for the time and she wasn't rewarded for it. It is getting better but it will never have gymnast try some great things and in certain combinations if they can't get bonus. I believe that someone is doing A score vids on here of old routines to todays code and its crazy to see what would pass today.
-
@adventuregirl76 I believe you were right when you posted this, but you have to agree that it has gotten better. I've definitely noticed the routines with less artistry getting lower scores.
-
@LCAmarkymark yes she was a gymnast way ahead of her time
-
What is the music..I just want to listen to you over and over
Back when choreography and artistry still mattered. Neither are rewarded under the current COP.
adventuregirl76 4 years ago 26
Beautiful, really fantastic.
Jimena08 4 years ago 20