Martha Argerich plays Bach toccata in C Minor BWV 911 PART 2
Top Comments
All Comments (323)
-
@laiholapso I am neither stupid, nor superficial. And before I judge a musician in such a harsh way like I did here, please be sure that I took the time to listen to several of her recordings. It gives me absolutely NO pleasure to criticise someone like that. But as someone who comes from a family of classical musicians, sorry, that's the way her music sounds to me. Please check out SIMONE DINNERSTEIN ! She feels, understands and loves every tone in Bach's music, showing how full of life it is
-
@Musicsson how dumb must you be to judge a person by one performance
-
Sorry, but her playing is... sh*t. To me, even the spaces between single notes sound irregular. And I` m not talking about the general tempo - she doesn't feel the "spaces", so the melodies don't flow. In german you say: "es klingt holzig" wich means that it sounds "wooden" / "holzig", like walking with wooden legs. Sorry, I think Bach wouldn't have been very pleased by her playing...
-
Why such raves for this? It's so simple I could play it with one finger.
-
@AnaMTrenchiBottazzi If the call someone the best, they don't claim to jugde objectively. They just are overwhelmed, their hearts are brimming over.
-
Me parece que Martha hace maravillosa música de la partitura de un maravilloso músico. Quien tenga un poco de sensibilidad artística se dará cuenta de que esto que oímos es un prodigio irrepetible, con el sello indiscutible del temperamento y la genialidad de una artista como las hay y las habrá pocas. Atentos saludos.
-
On l'attendais dans CHOPIN, mais non elle excelle aussi dans BACH, attention à l'addiction, être marié avec Martha ARGERICH le rêve.
-
Magnificient! Great heart, rhythmic pulse, and lyricism!!
-
Beau et cristallin, merci ♥
-
Fascinante!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!



Bach is simply the greatest ever.
jsnauwaert 11 months ago 22
I never understood why some people cannot enjoy many different interpretations and always have to decide which one is the best. If there is really A BEST ONE, we should not have so many artists performing the same piece. Only one would do it.
Also each person has his/her own taste, and what it is good for one it is bad for another. What makes anyone SO EXTRAORDINARY to be able to make the ultimate decision that it is the BEST? What an arrogance!!!!
AnaMTrenchiBottazzi 6 months ago 17