Lily's Eyes- The Secret Garden
Uploader Comments (achiles05)
Top Comments
-
No I didn't enjoy, but nice try. If anything, the two of you should have switch roles but besides that----stay away from musical theatre like this. There are other shows made for pop riffs, but not The Secret Garden
-
Dear God...please sing in tune....
All Comments (40)
-
Good instrument. Take voice lessons.
-
It's great! What u haters talking about!
-
It's poppy. I agree..
BUT I LOVE IT ANYWAY!!! ^.^
I'm a musical junkie, and this is really the first time I've ever liked a musical theater song changed into a song with a bit of pop to it.
Good job!!!! ^.^
-
whoever said you sound like backstreet boys was right. this was good but waaaaay too "poppy" for this beautiful song
-
Whoever was doing Archie's part was almost good enough to do this. A little flat and the whole rifting crap is really not doing anything for the song.
-
oh my god..you can't sing this song like a bloody Backstreet boys' song..too much air in the voice...no dinamics..and you CAN'T make your pop variations when you sing together..it's just..you CAN'T! This song is so beautiful as it is..a personal interpretation doesn't mean going towards the nature of the tack!
its kinda like when aretha franklin or micheal bolton did Nessum Dorma Its scary. You guys have cool voices but not for this song. Get about 4 years worth of training in classical music then try to sing it again!
sostenuto99 3 years ago
why not say 5 years? and what is equivalent to "4 years worth"?
achiles05 3 years ago
hope u didnt ruin any other musicals, stick to the justin temberlake crap
crazychris122090 3 years ago 2
but change is the beautiful thing about musical theater. even if it was intended to be sung a particular way that does not mean our interpretation of it is wrong. it's just like most literature or art. Look at the Mona Lisa for instance; my opinion may be wrong from what the painter intended, but who are you to tell me that I am wrong...and music changes, styles change, voices change. the freedom is what makes musical theater so much fun. you shouldn't conform to everyone else. be original
achiles05 3 years ago
@achiles05 Pretty sure that the song HAS a story behind it because it's in a musical. Let's say you had these leads and sang this song/all of the songs you had like this but everyone else sang them as they were intended.....uhm....you're not better...you're worse. The show takes place back then, not modern times. Would you make Mozart's music pop? Anyways, great job singing flat. WAY flat.
machihuahua 2 years ago
people do that all the time e.g. sing for the moment by eminem (uses an old aerosmith song). people do remixes all the time. and the story by itself can have any interpretation. it could be two guys singing about a girl that they lost. i never said i was better, and some of the notes were rough. i agree. but if you hadn't noticed, we didn't do the show. we did one song. and there were a couple pop inflections but i do not have a pop voice. and you can't talk shit until you put up your own videos
achiles05 2 years ago