Maria Stuarda Contest - Ashley Putnam - Marisa Galvany
Loading...
Top Comments
All Comments (51)
-
@MastersoftheOpera What do you mean UNDER the "Direction" of Sills? Sills was the head of the City Opera in '81.Your point being?So what?She did not direct this! Sills did not record Stuarda "with" DG, but for ABC/Westminster, not even a major label. DG now owns the rights to this recording.As for Farrell:she never sang this role on the stage. She sings all the notes in the recording but doesn't BEGIN to have the temperament of Galvany, let alone the high notes. Galvany had temperament to spare!
-
This Stuarda, New York City Opera 1981, was under the Direction of Beverly Sills, who had retired the year before. It used the same sets and costumes. Ashley Putnam looks lovely and has a lovely voice but I'm afraid she was very boring and she could not fill Sills' shoes in the role. Galvany as the Queen was nothing particularly special when compared to Eileen Farrell in the Sills recording with DG. I've heard this scene sung better. This was very dull.
-
I am gonna do Elisabetta for my master exam in december. I must say I have fallen in love with Marisa Galvany's voice. What a powerful instrument! I'll give Galvany a 5/5. Ashley Putnam sounds great too.
-
if you mean Putnam is more pleasant to listen to than Anderson, I agree.
-
i just did a masterclass with her at Manhattan School of Music, and she is absolutely fabulous. She talks about how during any scene she was so afraid she would be shaking beforehand. So even the greats get nervous. And she is such a good teacher
-
my god, they both did the high D ending...that doesnt happen all that often.
-
wow putnam had some pipes...
-
shes on the staff at the manhattan school of music now i believe.
-
5/5 Hands down the best in this role!!!
9:31
Maria Stuarda Contest - Mariella Devia - Marianna Pentchevaby coloraturafan4,889 views- 7:02
Maria Stuarda Contest - Edita Gruberova - Agnes Baltsaby coloraturafan34,002 views
- 9:51
Maria Stuarda Contest - Janet Baker - Rosalind Plowrightby coloraturafan9,298 views
- 9:22
Maria Stuarda Contest - Katia Ricciarelli - Glenys Linosby coloraturafan5,080 views
- 9:19
Montserrat Caballe & Bianca Berini "Queens Confrontation" Maria Stuardaby Onegin6514,227 views
- 5:01
Mozart, La Clemenza di Tito: S'altro che Lacrimeby haygraphics2,421 views
- 7:17
Montserrat Caballe "Preghiera" Maria Stuardaby Onegin6514,417 views
- 7:06
Maria Stuarda Contest - Gabriele Fontana - Joyce DiDonatoby coloraturafan6,468 views
- 9:19
Maria Stuarda Contest - Montserrat Caballé - Bianca Beriniby coloraturafan4,417 views
- 5:55
Marisa Galvany - Anna Bolena, Finale (New York Opera, 1974)by primohomme1,630 views
- 9:26
Maria Stuarda Contest - Tiziana Fabbricini -Gloria Scalchiby coloraturafan3,447 views
- 7:15
Joyce DiDonato - Maria Stuardaby hotazzoperastud20,102 views
- 0:21
backbend stuntby daniellecassity3,885 views
- 8:09
Marisa Galvany - Nabucco '81 NYC Opera (private film)by StuartLou451 views
- 9:57
Martina Arroyo - Mignon Dunn - Fu la sorte - Aida - 1983by coloraturafan25,196 views
- 4:24
Cecilia Bartoli - Armatae face et anguibusby cis84muz121,942 views
- 7:44
Rosalind Plowright - Il Pirata Finaleby coloraturafan3,822 views
- 5:09
Joan Sutherland - Era desso il figlio mioby bdl88again39,719 views
- 4:03
Duo Abigaille Nabuccoby vilaph3,317 views
- 6:42
Donald Smith & Joan Sutherland - Maria Stuarda Act 2 Duetby robmanrico1,292 views
Who wants "A New Sutherland"? How about unique personalities and voices for a change?
Elisabetta611 3 years ago 4
5/5 This is the best.
MaterDolorosa26 4 years ago 2