Une session de psychothérapie cognitive avec Albert Ellis (1)
Top Comments
All Comments (43)
-
I felt uneasy watching this. Notice that Gloria only smoked when she was with Perls and Ellis but not with Rogers. Even though I get what he is trying to do with Gloria, I don't think his style creates an environment that promote exploration. I got a feeling that he thinks "i know what I'm doing, and you don't". That must have been really frustrated Gloria.
-
@robboholic You're clueless. Utterly clueless. SHE was the one who brought up Jane Doe. He was pointing out/challenging her that her beliefs were irrational, which they were. Don't comment if you don't understand at least that much.
-
@joelmbarr Haha the ABCD model is evidence based, unlike psychoanalytic/Rogerian nonsense. Talk about blubbering about life. Unbelievable.
-
@robboholic Research doesn't support that opinion. Cbt/rebt is the most effective therapy...I hope you're not a therapist!
-
@mikeyo1234 You don't understand his technique. Try researching it. He is challenging her irrational thoughts and pointing out how she tells herself unreasonable things. Much better than the emotional, do-nothing Rogers approach.
-
@Wanderer123 The type of client who has irrational, black and white thinking. Do you seriously not understand that??
-
@fromhell1959 You couldn't be more wrong. He is never a bully, he is helping people understand how to THINK about how they think. Only an emotional goof would mistake that for bullying.
-
Well, if you think Ellis is overly aggressive here, check him out in the Ellis Institute DVD 'Coping with the suicide of a loved one'...the word 'bullying' comes to mind!!! Pity because there is some really great stuff in the REBT model which he pioneered. What an irony then that he seems to be solely responsible for giving it a bad name.
-
wow, I don't have a long enough attention span to keep up with Ellis....
-
Her problem seems to be mostly ego... e.g. "I won't get what _I_ want".
He has awful technique... too aggressive, but it was probably good for it's time.
thanks for the video
phillipbob 2 years ago 12
"I felt more cool toward Dr. Ellis. I did not have enough feeling. I was so busy tying to think with him that I didn't have enough feeling there. And I feel that most ah oh ah the biggest amount of emotions came up with me and Dr. Perls." She shows here that she thinks that she's supposed to feel rather than think during therapy; and her bias in this regard may have interfered with her clearly focusing on and hearing some of the things I said to her. (Ellis cited in Shostrom E.L 1965)
RyBawwwws 1 year ago 8