She was the favourite of Roshan, SDB, LP, KA, Naushad, SJ, Anil Biswas, Chitragupt, Hemant Kumar, C Ramchandra, Vasant Desai, Ghulam Mohammed, Salil Chaudhary, Madan Mohan etc. It is ludicrious to say it was because of any unfariness on her part. It is also a pitiable attempt to insult all these music directors! Lata was the need of the hour, but as happens to successful people, unfair criticisms like the one you have made, came her way. She chose to ignore them: that's all they were worth.
Talat's voice in this song as in all others, is as if he hasn't had any breakfast. Lata in this song is fantastic, and absolutely not unpleasant. Her voice control is marvellous and simply superhuman in this song, unlike the shaky voice of Talat. If she had control over the industry, it was because of her superior talents! She was far better at ghazals, classical songs and many other genres than Geeta and possessed far better diction.
Lata's voice is sweet in all pitches.
tymesqr100 1 year ago
very nice song thanks
monalovely 1 year ago
perfect song by lata ji touches soul and all emotions hats off
adamsin29 1 year ago
My god, had never heard Lata's version....her's is even better than Talat's as it sounds here...............
Rmehtacpa 2 years ago
It is futile to argue who is better. Just enjoy!
ribandarcho 3 years ago
Sacrilege! Lata never been good at high pitch?!! Excuse me! Atrocious is the word...
saki0991 3 years ago
She was the favourite of Roshan, SDB, LP, KA, Naushad, SJ, Anil Biswas, Chitragupt, Hemant Kumar, C Ramchandra, Vasant Desai, Ghulam Mohammed, Salil Chaudhary, Madan Mohan etc. It is ludicrious to say it was because of any unfariness on her part. It is also a pitiable attempt to insult all these music directors! Lata was the need of the hour, but as happens to successful people, unfair criticisms like the one you have made, came her way. She chose to ignore them: that's all they were worth.
pqrxyzus 3 years ago
Talat's voice in this song as in all others, is as if he hasn't had any breakfast. Lata in this song is fantastic, and absolutely not unpleasant. Her voice control is marvellous and simply superhuman in this song, unlike the shaky voice of Talat. If she had control over the industry, it was because of her superior talents! She was far better at ghazals, classical songs and many other genres than Geeta and possessed far better diction.
pqrxyzus 3 years ago
Agreed. As wonderful as Lata is, she's unlistenable in the high pitch portions of this song.
srazdan 3 years ago
This song was designed for Talat's voice and will some music lover will upload it on Youtube
Viswanathan
viswan1942 3 years ago