Reem Kelani singing 'Yafa'
Top Comments
All Comments (19)
-
Rofl. Okay. I don't quite understand how one is to tell a musician how he/she must express his/her interpretation of music and poetry. Plenty of opera singers even monks also sing and chant with the same emotion shown by Ms. Kelani. There is absolutely nothing wrong or deranged about it. Her music is also specific to her and obviously does not represent the entirety of Arab culture. Nonetheless, she does an amazing job.
-
Yes actually, I am a human being. And this is not singing with emotions. This is singing with fake contrived overdone emotions which mis-represents Arabic music to a bunch of Orientalists who know nothing about Arabic culture.
-
Singing with emotion makes you deranged? Are you a human being?
-
-In harmony...all love
-
OH MY GOD...
AMAZING PIANIST...!!!
-
Distinguished Syrian music critic Rashed Issa on Reem Kelani live:
"I was one of many stunned members of the audience who recently attended a concert, by Palestinian singer Reem Kelani at the Syrian Opera House in Damascus. This was not only because we witnessed a style of singing which is so against the current trend, but also because of the richness and multifarious talents in view in one personality."
-
Rashad Abou Shawar on Reem Kelani singing 'Yafa':
Another of Kelanis choices is Yafa! a poem in classical Arabic by Jaffa-born poet and mythologist Mahmoud Salim al-Hout. Kelani sings this poem as a recitation, utilising her broad vocal range in combination with the power of the piano. And she does so in a fashion that is positively heart-wrenching as she wails her way through al-Houts simple yet sublime poetry, protesting against the injustice of expelling Palestinians from their homeland.
-
You might not like the style of Reem Kelani or the quality of her voice, and that is your right. But to call her 'deranged' and 'confusing her self with Saleh Abd el-Hayy' is neither objective nor professional.
Kind regards,
M. Saffouri
-
She is confusing herself with Saleh Abd el-Hayy. Unfortunately most foreign listeners will fail to detect that this is not normal singing.
-
what makes you say that?
Exquisite, tear-ful.
I am an American who has seen what is left of old Jaffa. How the Israelis have used the homes and shops of the dispossessed Palestinians as an "exotic" setting for up-scale shops and restaurants.
How it must hurt a Palestinian to recall the time and place that is no more.
Brava, Ms. Reem!
summud 2 years ago 12
Very moving indeed. We will neve forget our beloved Yafa. And well done for such a fine performance.
Saffouri 3 years ago 9