How Patent Trolls Kill Innovation

"My statement to someone that is the victim of a patent troll lawsuit is that you are completely screwed," says Austin Meyer, who is himself the target of a so-called "patent troll" lawsuit.

Meyer is a software developer and aviation enthusiast. His two passions intersected in the '90s when he created a flight simulator called X-Plane, which quickly grew in popularity, outlasting even the once-popular Microsoft Flight Simulator. As many software developers do, Meyer made his application available on mobile devices like the iPhone and Android. And this is where he first ran into trouble.

A company called Uniloc has sued Meyer for patent infringement over a patent called, "System and Method for Preventing Unauthorized Access to Electronic Data." When a computer runs a paid application, one way that developers can assure that a customer has actually purchased the application is by coding the application to match a license code with an encrypted database. This is a method that most paid applications on the Android market use. It's a method that Meyer argues has been in use since at least the late '80s. This is the idea that Uniloc claims to own.

"A patent troll is a company, a person... who owns patents, but doesn't make anything or sell anything," says Julie Samuels, an attorney and the Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents at the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

Samuels says that patent trolls are a huge tax on innovation and add nothing valuable to the marketplace. A study out of Boston University estimates the direct economic damage that patent trolls cause to be around $29 billion a year, and this doesn't account for hush-hush, off-the-record settlements. But the bigger problem, says Samuels, is the patent system itself.

"You can't separate the problem with the patent troll from the problem with software patents," says Samuels. "There are hundreds of thousands of software patents floating around that are really broad, that are really vague ... and a lot of them are bought up by patent trolls."

A Yale study found that the U.S. patent office is approving new software patents at an approximate rate of 40,000 a year. That's more than 100 new software patents every day. Tracking every software patent to make sure one is not in violation would be an utter impossibility without a full-time team of lawyers on staff.

Uniloc, which purchased the patent in question at a bankruptcy proceeding, declined an interview request for this piece. But on their website, they brag about a victory over software giant Microsoft resulting in $388 million in damages (though this amount was later lowered in an appeals court). Despite the enormous risk, and the enormous cost just to defend against a patent suit, Meyer is resolved to do so.

"I will not simply give somebody money that endorses the idea that they should sue people for doing something amazing," says Meyer. "It must be stopped at some point."

About 6 minutes.

Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Shot by Amanda Winkler, Tracy Oppenheimer, and Weissmueller. Music by Case Newsom, Broke for Free, and Pionir.

Visit Reason TV for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.

• Category

  News & Politics

[QwazyWabbit]

Software is an algorithm. Algorithms cannot be patented. How has this escaped the law? End software patents now.

[CmdrGendoIkari]

Yep, I also have had a few patentable ideas that I couldn't afford to go through with patenting, only to see them pop up years later in the market. Unfortunately, the high cost of the patenting process prices regular people right out of being able to do it.

[tubal1]

So, they are not suing Meyer for the X-Plane program, but for the delivering sytem used to distribute the flight simulator (this thing with the code, which is also another program).

So, where did he get the delivery system/software from? or did he write it by himself? Because this system is widely used by million people worldwide and I'm wondering if all these app developers are paying Uniloc every time a user downloads/pays for one their apps.

[Slambog]

Why does this guy remind me of Will Ferrell but with a high pitched voice

[interstink]

Blame our Patent system, our US government, and lobbyists. Patent Trolls found an amazing business model that works (Legal Extortion). The history of the Mob and gangsters used this same method, and now its legal and being applied to crush the US. Its no wonder China is winning.

[biolinkstudios]

i can see why are tech cost so much now, its not the person that makes it, its the Patent Trolls kill them now!

[debendra gurung]

Apple is to blame for this. They are the one who exploited using patents to create billions. I think these are the same Fxxkers who helped Apple to create billions. Patents should be matters of pride and dignity and not venture into capitl markets. And Apple, u take all ur patents and shove it up your billion dollar ass. I dont give a sht.......

[DorkVader26]

I think if you came up with a useful algorithm you'd want to get paid for it...

[DorkVader26]

Patent trolls aren't the only law firms that do this. Most law firms nothin short of legal extortion firms. The slip and fall attorneys and firms. For example.

[ZotDudot7]

Boycott and petition Uniloc.