Uploader Comments (IsaacR312)
Top Comments
-
That was so cute. Isn't Melinda AMAZING???
-
Yeah. I stopped watching too after she lost. The show lost all it's credibility with me at that point.
All Comments (24)
-
There is a level of talent to sophisticated for the Idol. The elimination of Pia proved that yet again. If you hear Melinda and you are not moved, you are not human. She sings with a purity that only a kind decent person can deliver. She really feels it, she really means it.
-
i think she owned this song, much better actually the withney houston(however she is still god, but the crack messed up her voice)
-
Her voice is so pure. She reminds me of Karen Carpenter and the early years of Whitney Houston. Too bad she didn't win, which I think she should have.
-
she should have won that season! She is the best in AL history!
-
i believe that it was intended that she said Johnson since they laughed when the governor said the wrong surname.
-
The Governor said Randy Johnson and then she repeated him in jest.
-
is it me or did she say "Thank you Randy Johnson" ? lollll Other than that, Melinda is awesome!!!!
-
0:31 did she say randy johnson ?
-
I havent been able to watch much of Idol since this girl lost. For many seasons, this is the best contestant on the show. And she didn't make it?



'thank you randy johnson'...melinda's cutest moment...ps she owned this song
mzzh 4 years ago
LOL! Yeah, that was hilarious! Randy Johnson!? lol
IsaacR312 4 years ago
Um, don't people hear the whole thing? The governor mistakenly said "Randy Johnson" which was why Melinda laughed and then copied him and said Johnson as well.
maricelei 4 years ago
Ha. Weird. I never caught that. I guess I should learn to pay more attention! :D Well, she did great on the song!
IsaacR312 4 years ago