AVGN/Nostalgia Critic Contest

Well, hi it's been a while.
Well with no doubt about 98% of people watching this video will most likely know who the AVGN (James Rolfe) and the Nostalgia Critic (Douglas Walker) are, and you most certainly know about the contest they ran a few weeks ago. Now each one of them did their reviews and then said nothing, except for the Critic who bowed to continue the battle.
I however am curious to see who the majority of us here at Youtube think did better. This time is pretty simple just choose the review (Not the reviewer) you though made a better video and just post his name.
I am aware that we may be throwing more wood into the fire with this one but it's time to find out which review was better.
So just vote away.
One thing though: I edited the videos so they would fit into the 10 minute time limit


If you would like to see the complete videos to make up your mine the here are the links:

Ricky 1 Review:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpMxy_ydnMM

Bebe's Kids:

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/nostalgia-c...


UPDATE:
09/25/2008
Given the recent progress of event I am cutting the voting limit to august 7 so I can post it on the 9th

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Angry
• Video
• Game
• Nerd
• Nostalgia
• Critic
• Movie
• Review

[TexasProudCowgirl]

You do know they're friends in real life, right?

[RaizingArizona]

I can't really like one more than the other. They're both just awesome.

[Raider768]

I love and admire both the Critic and the Nerd, but in this case, the NC wins. He took his time to play with this idea of reviewing a video game in lieu of a movie. We get a solid performance out of James but it left me wanting more. James is very imaginative and a great filmmaker. But here we get standard Nerd. Nothing new. The Critic actually gets more creative nearly parodying both his and James' respective style. So point goes to Doug.

[SWARVB]

Nostalgia critic

[GoodFebruarian]

@RaizingArizona Aye, i second your opinion, sir~

[Sdudeobacon]

7:47, wow, the kind of violence with an inanimate object, without blood, and for some reason, still gruesome as fuck!!! Am I really that obsessed with video games?

[TheTsugnawmi2010]

NC was more entertaining

AVGN was more informing

[fyzy03]

Both r gud... :D

[neeger123f]

look at 7:33 you can see the timer up there that shows 34 seconds left,then a second later its 3seconds.faker

[sdude456]

Wow... yelling louder does not = being more funny.

[pressuredcontents]

for these specific reviews, NC wins for sure. but as a whole and for most videos, avgn is my favorite.

[Rasberd]

NC won this one....i am da biggest fan for both....but i think dat Nc review wuz better