http://www.smarttrades.com For educational purposes only. No claims of profitability for any systems or methods posted.
For more frequent reports visit SmartTrades.com
Entire publication © Smart Trades Inc. 2010 All rights reserved.
All Charts & Quote Pages in this publication made with Omega Trade Station (r) 8
This post is for educational purposes only.
TRADE AT YOUR OWN RISK!
NOTICE: Traders can and do lose money. No claims are made that the information provided here will insure gains or prevent loses. TRADE AT YOUR OWN RISK.
All support, education and training services and materials in this post are for informational and educational purposes only. No type of trading or investment recommendation, advice or strategy is being made, given or in any manner provided by Smart Trades Inc. or its affiliates.
NOTICE: Neither the information, the systems, nor any opinion expressed herein constitutes a representation by Smart Trades Inc., or a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any commodity futures, other securities, or options of any kind. Those using the information and systems herein for trading purposes are responsible for their own actions and no claim is made that the recommendations or systems will be profitable or that they will not result in losses. Smart Trades owners, employees, or members of their families may have a position in the markets contrary to the information or systems contained herein. TRADE AT YOUR OWN RISK.
PLEASE NOTE THAT THERE IS AN INHERENT RISK OF LOSS ASSOCIATED WITH TRADING FUTURES AND OPTIONS CONTRACTS, EVEN WHEN USED FOR HEDGING PURPOSES. PLEASE CAREFULLY CONSIDER YOUR FINANCIAL CONDITION BEFORE INVESTING IN FUTURES AND OPTIONS CONTRACTS. FUTURES TRADING IS NOT SUITABLE FOR ALL INVESTORS. NO CLAIMS ARE MADE THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED HERE WILL INSURE GAINS OR PREVENT LOSES. TRADE AT YOUR OWN RISK.
PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT NECESSARY INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS.
Smart Trades Update 7.13.11 Long term Dow alternative to Prechter, S&P, Crude, NG, Dollar, Gold
@ctrader09 Look at your own copy of Prechter's long term count....call 1932 a 1-2 instead of (III)-(IV) (note there is no alternation in your/RP's (II) and (IV) waves). Also note *all* of your counts, even your "bullish alternate" counts, have been wrong (too bearish). The market is talking to you, but you only have ears for Mr Prechter's Super Cycle Bear song....
T1systems 7 months ago
@T1systems The fact that it extended that far, if anything, would portend a bigger top than he expected, not a smaller one. Also regarding the CRB, commodities exhibit ABC overlapping patterns. So the the series of 1-2's isn't necessarily, or likely, correct.
ctrader09 7 months ago
@ctrader09 He was decisively bearish in October 1987. He said : "the Grand Supercycle bear market has begun". Just because he didn't write a book that year, or some folks here weren't born yet, it doesn't change the fact. Here's the point: if the market extends 3400% beyond were it "should", it's likely you're off by a degree of scale. That's exactly what's happened, yet all the newbie "Elliotticians" cling to some variation of Prechter's original count....
T1systems 7 months ago
@T1systems No extended from 1995 when he turned decisively bearish with his first bearish book.
ctrader09 7 months ago
@ctrader09 I guess you weren't around circa 1987, nor did you read my answer. Prechter called the top in 1987 @ NDX 137 or so. That's 13 years early no matter how you count it. Oct 22, 1987 if memory serves, just after that crash. So you're saying his 1987 count is "right" and it's just an extended 5th (2280% extention basis the NDX)?
T1systems 7 months ago
@T1systems Certainly wise to have an open mind, but the reason Prechter was 5 years early in calling for the bear market to begin was that the 5th wave extended. He didn't account for that when he should have considering the size of the top that was building. Then it extended into 2007 with a divergence between the DOW and the COMP/NDX. There is a pattern on the DOW I am watching that is extremely bearish long term, and that is a megaphone top. this would allow one more all-time high.
ctrader09 7 months ago
@ctrader09 Google "CRB back to 1450" I count I-II-1-2-i-ii-iii on that chart.......what do you count please? The bottom line is we *don't* know exactly where we are in very long term counts.....
T1systems 7 months ago
@ctrader09 If the market doesn't confirm the pattern I'm looking for, then I look to re-evaluate. There's some evidence (24 years and 11,000 Dow points, *3400%* in the NDX) that RP's original assumptions are off. I think it's wise to have an open mind to an alternate scenario. The logical alternative is that we've had a series of 1-2's rather than 3-4's. How else do you explain the best Elliott Wave analyst in the world circa 1987 being so far off?
T1systems 7 months ago
@ctrader09 Sure it's possible. Essentially this has been Prechter's call since October 1987 when he said: "the Grand Supercycle bear market has begun"....targeting 40-381 Dow. Or how about circa Oct 1995, he said: "the message is unequivocal, portending a record setting collapse in stock prices...." when the Nasdaq was in the 500's (NDX eventually hit 4800). As a trader and analysts I have a set of expectations based on the patterns that I assume to be correct.
T1systems 7 months ago
Hi Bill, I tend to favor a move down to DOW 570, as it is the cycle wave 4 low, and the beginning of the great asset mania. Historically, the ending point of manias is below the start. Hopefully we switch monetary systems before ALL of the credit inflation from the 1930's is undone and we are at DOW 40.
ctrader09 7 months ago