Umineko explained - Detailed analysis of all the key scenes of "Umineko no naku koro ni"

DISCLAIMER FOR VIEWERS WHO READ ALL THE NOVELS:

I have read all the novels as well by now and even interviews with the author. So I am very much aware of the whole Shkanon and yasu stuff. So I know what the official explanation is. HOWEVER, I dont believe for a second that the official explanation is true or even could be true. My position is that the author (Ryukishi07) is lying, yes you read that correcly, is lying regarding the truth behind the story. The whole Shkanontrice explanation and such is a DECEPTION to hide the real truth behind. Yes this may sound like a crazy position, but in my upcoming "Umineko Chiru Explained" video I will thoroughly defend this position and demonstrate with tons of evidence that the official explanation is a lie. The evidence against Skhanontrice is truly massive and the evidence in favor of it is actually very weak and even conflits with red statements. And in place of the "official explanation" I will put a coherent, consistent, plausible and non-ambigious explanation that is accounts for all that needs to be accounted for (including Yasu and Battler's sin against Shannon) is consistent with all evidence and all red statements which includes the who-dunnit, how-dunnit and why-dunnit. And that theory is for the most part the same as my original theory in this video. Main difference is that in my original theory I had George as the Major culprit and Rosa as the minor culprit. In my final theory it is the exact other way around. Looking back, my original theory in this video was not that well supported, but my final theory will be extremely well supported with tons of evidence, including evidence that suggests that Ryukishi is indeed lying regarding the truth behind the story from hints within the story itself and evidence from interviews. So stay tuned for Umineko Chiru explained!


all rights belong to 7th expansion and studio deen. I don't own any of the rights. I merely use these clips under fair use.

time marks:

part 1: who is the real culprit? 5:45

Part 2: Who is Beatrice? 19:31

Part 3: explaining the first game. 33:45

Part 4: explaining the second game. 53:28

Part 5: explaining the third game. 1:13:34

Part 6: explaining the fourth game. 1:33:15

Part 7: alternative theories/motivations/explaing the meta-world. 1:47:38

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Umineko
• no
• naku
• koro
• ni
• explained
• theory
• episode
• Battler
• culprit
• golden
• witch
• beatrice
• when
• they
• cry
• seagulls
• bernkastel
• higurashi
• magic
• anime
• visual
• novel
• explanation
• Rosa
• George
• Nanjo
• Maria
• Eva
• Shannon
• Kanon
• Genji
• Ghoda
• Kinzo
• Kumasawa
• Hideyoshi
• Kyrie
• Rudolf
• Krauss
• Natsuhi
• Bernkastel
• Lambdadelta
• Virgillia
• witches
• murder
• detective
• solve
• solved
• truth
• smallbombs
• english
• subs
• smallbombschiru
• 10
• 11
• 12
• 13
• 14
• 15
• 16
• 17
• 18
• 19
• 20
• 21
• 22
• 23
• 24
• 25
• 26
• うみねこ
• うみねこのなく頃に

[Sassygir1s2]

@KnownNoMore

Yes I read all the way to EP 7 and aware of the Beatrice=Shannon=Kannon thing but I was thinking of "official explanation" as something different. I haven't read EP 8 but I read the summary & it seems that the true culprit is never explicitly revealed. That's what I meant by no official explanation because(correct me if I'm wrong)we never really know what happened during Oct. 4~5 on Rokkenjima for sure other than the fact that at the end everyone died except Eva and Battler.

[KnownNoMore]

@Sassygir1s2

'we never really know what happened during Oct. 4~5 on Rokkenjima for sure other than the fact that at the end everyone died except Eva and Battler."

We dont know that for sure at all. All we know is that in Ange's world Eva survived. We dont know if Eva survived during the real oct 4~5, in fact I think we have good reasons to believe that absolutely no one survived.

[Sassygir1s2]

"I only deny that the official explanation is the truth."

Wait, whaaaat? I thought there was no such thing as an official explanation. Is there? This is new for me...0_0 Whether it's true or not I would love to read it.

[KnownNoMore]

@Sassygir1s2

Have you read all 8 novels? Basically a straightforward interpretation of the 7th novel is the official explanation. I call it offical because this explanation is basically confirmed by the author in interview. Fans know it as the Shkanontrice theory. But there is not a detailed explanation of all the murders so even the official explanation for the most part merely tells you who did it and who beatrice is but is vague about the how-dunnit

[Luminethereploid]

I don't think Beatrice even can be Shannon. Because look! [red]The Ushiromiya family tatoo is on different legs on Beatrice and Shannon![/red]

[KnownNoMore]

@Luminethereploid

I actually use that argument in chiru explained, but there are stronger arguments against Shannon being Beatrice including conflicting red.

[KnownNoMore]

@foxinsocks88

"holy shit! :0 you must REALLY love this for you to do this much research"

The umineko novels are 8 volumes of literary genius. It deserves this much attention.

Also I'm pretty much insane.

[kaniini008]

This is really interesting, but I think that Eva could have killed Rudolf and Kyrie in the third game in two different ways: 1) If they for example accidentally killed Hideyoshi in the middle of interrogating him, the she would most likely revenge his death. Or 2) If she really did murder Rosa and Maria, and Rudolf and Kyrie were on the verge of finding it. After murdering them It is possible Hideyoshi confronted her, so she'd have to murder him too.

[FleetForSpeed]

@KnownNoMore

Will you post this theory in your videos?

I am very interested in the reasoning behind it.

Also, did you breeze right through this using your systematic logical reasoning? It seems to me that you rarely try to come up with explanations halfway through, but instead bring as many of the possibilities into the field from the very start, and pick them out one by one only by confirments of red truth, and even after you've interpreted that truth in every possible way. Yes?

[YamiAura]

@Luminethereploid [blue]they're not tattoos[/blue]

[Sassygir1s2]

@KnownNoMore I WAS referring to Ange's world when I said 'everyone died except Eva & Battler.' I know that in other Kakeras everyone's pretty much dead. But Eva & Battler's survival is the truth in that Kakera(Ange's world) is it not? At least it looks like that's how the story goes in the chapter ???? of EP 8. Of course I'm not saying I'm right because I'm so damn confused...=_= I'm really looking forward to your Chiru explanation because I pretty much gave up long ago XD

[KnownNoMore]

@IchibanOjousama

"So, from what I’ve read, you’re basically denying all Chiru?"

No absolutely not. I don't deny anything about Chiru at all. I only deny that the official explanation is the truth, in other words, that its a deceptive (and incoherent and contradictory and even violates red truths) interpretation and that there in fact does exists a coherent, consistent, possible and plausible interpretation. That's my position. I don't dismiss anything within the story itself