Defiance Film review by Kenneth Turan

Kenneth Turan reviews Defiance, staring Daniel Craig.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• kenneth
• Turan
• Jason
• Neubert
• Defiance
• Daniel
• Craig
• movie
• review
• reviews
• film
• news
• la
• los
• angeles
• times

[SANARIA7]

@HelgiWartooth777

I saw the programm with Polish witness accusing the Jews of Bielski of making this massacre. These Poles were there during massacre and they are sure that Jews of Bielski attacked their village and killed 128 Polish farmers. The Jews of Bielski had horrible opinion that time , because they terrorised all villages around , attacked them , stole their property. They behaved just like German occupants confiscataing almost all the food from poor farmers.

[SANARIA7]

@HelgiWartooth777

There were many Jews working with Hitler in holocaust- Jewish policemen in all the ghettos making deportations of hundreds thousands their jewish compatriots to death camps , judenraten - Jewish councils in ghettos collaborating with Hitler. Now the Jews don't want to remember about these ugly collaboration- they prefer to accuse people from Eastern Europe of collaboaration with nazists although they did just the same.

Absolutely just the same!

[HelgiWartooth777]

@SANARIA7 Yes of course, there was a war going on, and the Jews and the Soviets tried to survive in the forest the best way that they knew how. What comfort would you have offered them in their resistance against the Facists? Or were you a collaborator? There were many people in Eastern Europe who worked with Hitler in 1941 when the Germans attacked, after all, it looked to many, even Stalin that the Nazis might win the war.There were a few however who stood against the Nazis!

[HelgiWartooth777]

@bambusowaty Lies? What proof do you offer? Were you there with them in the woods at the time? This movie is but a tiny fragment of what went on, but no student of history could call this movie a bunch of lies without knowing all the facts. What facts do you offer?

[klausmann111]

This movie is not a lie,the history show a lot of records abaut the resistence of the jews in the woods & the fact that some of those resistent groups could kill some polish do not make them criminals,in this war the fact was the supervivence,some polish also denunced & killed jews just to recieved some money or to stole the jews properties,or simpy they denunced them knowsing that the end of those denunced was the deported to dead of the victims.

[klausmann111]

Sanarya,u know better than me that the heroes can be bandits or real heroes ,it depends the roll of theym in the history & it depends the interpretation ,in what side they were,u the polish had a lot of " heroes" who in fact were antisemits bandits,now let the polish jews have his own heroes like the bielkies,in fact they defended the jews from the polish antisemites who denunced the jews & colaborated with the nazis in the murder of them,i,m saying some polish not all of them .

[bambusowaty]

why did they make film about heroes based on real history of a coward, traitor and murdurer Tewje Bielski. this story is full of lies. please dont call me an antisemite just because the main characters are jews

[therealreason100]

fuck nazi scum

[SANARIA7]

This movie is a lie! These briothers Bielski were bandits: they reguralry attacked polish villages to steal food and other values things. They were rapists. Their people took part in Naliboki's crime: 8.05.1943 Soviets and Jews of Bielski attacked polish viilage Naliboki and killed 128 polish pesant in revenge because Poles defended their village from thievery of jewish and Soviet gangsters from the forests.

[BOJANGLES356]

this movie was fantastic