Bach - Art of the Fugue BWV 1080 - Contrapunctus VIII & XIII
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (34)
-
I once read that more recently there's a been tendency among most experts to consider that the Art of the Fuge was written for the keyboard. Personally I think it would make sense because I find it sounds most convincing played on a keybord (my personal preference being the modern piano), even though this particular interpretation is very good too.
-
这 个 三奏 !版 本售 重 是 平 生 第 一 次 听 到,欢不知里有由衷道哪地喜
-
@RainMan34 This is actualy very true.
-
No, but I did stay at a holiday inn express last night. (and every other night for which I was explaining myself here, albeit poorly)
And to be sure, I was talking completely out of my ass. I haven't read enough Bach scores vs. baroque scores of the time to make any credible statements regarding unedited vs edited baroque scores
Fair?
-
I would like to ask out of curiosity and not sarcasm whether you've had the opportunity to look at an unedited Bach score, or any unedited baroque score for that matter. Scores in the Baroque period had about two expression markings: forte and piano. Of particular ambiguity is the art of the fugue, of which it cannot be definitively said what instrument(s) the work was written for.
-
it's probably an attempt to blend the modern and baroque world, a little humorous approach if you ask me.
-
I agree with you Rain... Bach although could be played differently should be only played as precisely as is intended from the day he wrote them



i like the candle vids on the tv's!
rosescentedshit 9 months ago 3
@RainMan34
quite fair. i'm rather surprised and impressed by your honesty.
cheers!
cameronorr 2 years ago 2