Brand New vs. Taking Back Sunday (and vice-versa) Pt. I

Brand New.
Taking Back Sunday.
First albums.
More to come.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• brand
• new
• taking
• back
• sunday
• john
• nolan
• jesse
• lacey

[imthenextjlacey]

brand new wins end of story. tbs was good until john left.

[ctram527]

@MrSodaBelly brand new has not become pop. the devil and god was a masterpiece.

[RayXo9]

I have to say TBS wins this round. If it was Deja or Devil and God, then maybe I'd change my decision.

[Fraansv]

taking back sunday <3

[FLETCHthedubs]

@ctram527 I listen to old brand new after the devil and god and think Jess went in reverse to most punk bands, got more real and honest than he could even imagine when he was making deja and your favorite weapon. and then had the talent and the balls to put it out there for us to hear. I don't know if it sold more than the first two but to make that drastic of a change in your self portrait to the world is inspiring to me

[butimeantlove]

Everything past makedamnsure was a disaster. ick.

[butimeantlove]

LOL brand new became pop? no way. fucking tbs turned pop. sold out. brand new has remained true to their selves. <3 br&new.

MICS ARE FOR SINGING, NOT SWINGING.

[gregtheinfinite]

@lizardgizard222 Were you dropped on your head?

[lizardgizard222]

Taking back Sunday makes Wayyy more since and know what notes are...

[thekingoflalaland]

@Rodgers2raw12 Tbs didn't sell out, they changed their style. As people grow up, the things they write about and the style of music they play changes. Brand new has a very different style now as the did in the beginning. and I never said one was better than the other. I said the both are awesome. both in my top five bands. but, people can have opinions on which is better music. They are different genres though. You cant say that one is more talented though because their talents are different.

[justbreathekids]

brand new has the best lyrics, hands down.

but taking back sunday puts me in a mood that nothing else can.

i don't think you can pick one better than the other, just thank

that bitch who split jesse and john; without her we wouldn't have

this debate.

so thank you, cheating whore (:

[MrTanz522]

i love both bands. i think tbs' old stuff was better than brand news old stuff but brand new's new stuff is hands down better than tbs. the devil and god is sick. i like tbs' new album too tho