Show Boat (1936) - Part 4/16: "Can't Help Lovin' That Man"

One of three film versions of the classic Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein stage musical, this Universal production is considered the best of the three by film critics and enthusiasts alike.

Premiering at Washington's National Theatre in the winter of 1927, the original stage show went on to continue its out-of-town tryout in a series of East Coast cities before finally making its Broadway debut at the Ziegfeld Theatre on 27 December, 1927. The original Broadway production was a huge success, playing over 500 performances. The show then embarked on a nation-wide tour after it completed its Broadway run in 1929.

Norma Terris, Broadway's original Magnolia Hawks, went off to Hollywood to make films and actress Irene Dunne took over the role for the remainder of the national tour, which disbanded in 1930.

A revival of the original Zeigfeld production opened at the Casino Theatre on Broadway in 1932. This first Broadway revival reunited much of the original cast and included the great bass Paul Robeson as Joe, for whom the role was actually written for. Unable to join the original production at the Ziegfeld due to other commitments, the role went to Jules Bledsoe. Prior to his appearance in the 1932 Broadway revival, Robeson had played the role in London for which he received critical acclaim and achieved overnight stardom.

After an unsuccessful attempt at converting a silent filmed version of Edna Ferber's novel of the same name--on which the show is based--into the much acclaimed musical version by overlaying musical numbers on the previously shot action, re-shooting key sequences, and incorporating sound, the film rights bought by Universal were put into good use, resulting in this critically acclaimed 1936 film version of the groundbreaking stage musical.

An unusual choice for director considering the genre was James Whale, but his attention to atmospheric detail made him an ideal choice. The head of Universal at the time insisted as much of the original Broadway cast as possible be brought in to do the film. Of those original cast members that eventually joined the film production were Charles Winninger as Captain Andy Hawks; Francis X. Mahoney as Rubberface Smith; Sammy White as Frank Schultz; and Helen Morgan as Julie LaVerne.

Also joining the production were Show Boat alumni Hattie McDaniel, who had appeared in the 1933 West Coast production, as Queenie; Paul Robeson as Joe; Allan Jones, who had appeared in a regional U.S. production, as Gaylord Ravenal; and Irene Dunne as Magnolia Hawks.

By far the most faithful to the original stage version, this 1936 film is almost word for word accurate with the exception of the much altered ending. A considerable amount of songs were cut due to time constraints (although bits remain in the underscoring) but the show's most memorable numbers remain.

CAST

Magnolia - Irene Dunne

Gaylord Ravenal - Allan Jones

Captain Andy Hawks - Charles Winninger

Joe - Paul Robeson

Julie - Helen Morgan

Parthy Ann Hawks - Helen Westley

Ellie - Queenie Smith

Frank - Sammy White

Steve - Donald Cook

Queenie - Hattie McDaniel

Rubber Face - Francis X. Mahoney

Kim (as child) - Marilyn Knowlden

Kim (at sixteen) - Sunnie O'Dea

Pete - Arthur Hohl

Vallon - Charles Middleton

Windy - J. Farrell MacDonald

Sam - Clarence Muse

Jim - Charles Wilson

Backwoodsman - Stanley Fields

Jake - Harry Barris

PRODUCTION TEAM

Director - James Whale

Producer - Carl Laemmle Jr.

Stage play, screenplay, and lyrics - Oscar Hammerstein II

Music - Jerome Kern

Cinematographer - John J. Mescall, A.S.C.

Special Cinematographer - John P. Fulton

Art Director - Charles D. Hall

Musical Director - Victor Baravalle

Costumes - Doris Zinkeisen

Choreography - LeRoy Prinz

Editors - Ted Kent, Bernard Burton

Orchestration - Robert Russell Bennett

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Show
• Boat
• 1936
• Oscar
• Hammerstein
• Jerome
• Kern
• Showboat
• Musicals
• Broadway
• Classic
• Irene
• Dunne
• Paul
• Robeson
• Allan
• Jones
• Hattie
• McDaniel
• Charles
• Winninger
• Helen
• Morgan
• Edna
• Ferber
• James
• Whale
• Theatre
• Ziegfeld
• Can't
• Help
• Lovin'
• That
• Man

[tracer740]

LaMisere- Your uploads are among the best on Youtube. Thank you for your taste, talent and efforts! I am forever appreciative.

[LaMisereHQ]

@tracer740 You're very welcome. Always happy to share the things that make me happy and have enriched my life. I'm glad there are still people out there who enjoy these musicals as much as I do.

[madamerotten]

Wonderful. 100 times more entertaining than anything Hollywood produces today.

[coolkid1234533]

@surgedeb She HAD more talent than you ever WILL HAVE. How is that for a comeback. And by the way, its called acting, she is supposed to look like that.

[andrebontemp]

what a joy to see the wonderful Hattie Mc Daniel in this musical I only knew the color version with Ava Gardner but I hope I could see this B & W version with theses great actors but Ava was spendid anyway

[awakenedlink37]

Mammy!

[wrenn23]

They don't make them this great anymore.

[lilithmoon1979]

OMG THAT VOICE OF THAT MAN!!!! hubba hubba!!!

[Axgoodofdunemaul]

Although I love this, and it's beautiful and heartfelt, the only authenticity about it is that it is the 20s New York City version of the Old South. I have wondered all my life how this style of music ever became associated with black American culture. In spite of that, Showboat touches, however lightly, on our American scourge of racism. Rare and courageous, even today!

[lonegeminielf2]

Where did you get this footage? Is it available on DVD? Anybody know?

[lonegeminielf2]

 I love this version. I have the Howard Keel version.Paul Robson's amazing voice and Hattie McDaniels great all round talent. She deserved that Academy Award.Great music from Kern and Hammerstein. Also Helen Morgan, as Julie was meant to be played by the author Edna Ferber.I do love Ava Gardner's soulful rendition of Can't help lovin that man of mine though. Ella Fitzgerald also has a lovely version. But then Ella did everything well. Thank you for posting!I must find this version.

[lonegeminielf2]

I love this version. I have the Howard Keel version.Paul Robson's amazing voice and Hattie McDaniels great all round talent. She deserved that Academy Award.Great music from Kern and Hammerstein. Also Helen Morgan, as Julie was meant to be played by the author Edna Ferber.I do love Ava Gardner's soulful rendition of Can't help lovin that man of mine though. Ella Fitzgerald also has a lovely version. But then Ella did everything well. Thank you for posting!I must find this version.

[grannysfilms]

They don't show this film on tv any more - only the crummy howard keel version. Such a pity.

[ebonics4everyone]

Slavery was sad. It was sad, when blacks had to be slaves in the South. It's also sad today in third world sweatshops in places like Vietnam and India. America was ruined by slavery in the 1800s with the civil war. Now America is being ruined morally and economically once again by modern slavery.