J.S.Bach - Singet dem Herrn ein neues Lied [3/3]
Uploader Comments (ybc2005)
All Comments (9)
-
Gar und ganz SCHRECKLICH! Armer Bach!
-
OMG!!! THIS IS SHOCKING!!! Please, please listen to some good recordings of the piece (Herreweghe, Suzuki etc.) and stop abusing Bach in this way!!!!!
Terrible!!!
-
Very interesting. I'm not sure about the excessive articulation - it sounds as if someone should be hyperventilating any second. Still, a good attempt.
-
the quality of the voices is very stranges, this "picato" of the sopranos, is not really beautifoul.. The Instruments should imitates the good singers (just as Telemann write in his autobiografy), not the inverse, singers imitatin bad insttrumentalist... too many articulations. See for example the introduction from bach self for the inventions for harpsiichord, he ask even harpsichordist to make cantabile... and you sing with a bad harpsichord player articulation
-
Professionelle Stimmen! - Gute deutsche Aussprache! - Aber diese durchweg "perforierte" Interpretation ist sicher nicht im Bach'schen Sinne!
-
全然ダメ。
でたらめなフレージングにアーティキュレーション、低い1コロの
ベース。 今後のご健闘をお祈りします。
-
Genial!!!



The pitch is extraordinary. Outside of the language challenge (which is to be expected) this was a very decent performance.
atshaw02 2 years ago
Thank you for listening.
To be honest, our pitch tend to approach baroque one, even started from modern!
ybc2005 2 years ago
There are major sound problems with thos - or the diction is askew Japonaisse/Deutsch
AndrewOrgelspieler 2 years ago
Thank you for your comment.
We also feel unstability due to insufficient warm-up, and inclusion of Japanese accent especially in 'Halleluja'.
We will improve.
ybc2005 2 years ago