George Parros vs Frazer McLaren Nov 9, 2010

George Parros vs Frazer McLaren from the Anaheim Ducks at San Jose Sharks game on Nov 9, 2010.
via http://www.hockeyfights.com

Category:

Sports

Tags:

• hockey
• fight
• fights
• george
• parros
• frazer
• mclaren
• anaheim
• ducks
• san
• jose
• sharks
• nhl

[gtrefghuk]

' the hell happend to Gorgeous Georges' stache? Did Frazer knock it off?

[MrHannan1992]

@braddyboy82 Okay well you wrote a shit load you could have condensed into two replies, but I guess that's okay. I will make my point short and sweet and maybe you will understand, somewhere in your head there is a brain I know it.

Would Carcillo have lead in PIM the years he did if you took away all of his fighting majors? Answer is no he wouldn't have. Just stop. If you lead in PIM, you have to have some level of fighting majors. Career highs don't matter to me, what matters is league leaders

[braddyboy82]

@MrHannan1992

Just using Anaheim Ducks players as examples (don't shake the beehive, player stats from other teams will hurt your case)...

Scott Neidermayer had a career high 96 PIM in the '05-'06 season, and Teemu Selanne (of all players) had 82 PIM the season the Ducks won the Stanley Cup.

No fighting majors between us. Soooooooooooooo... what was your point?

[braddyboy82]

@MrHannan1992

Wait wait wait, you said before that PIMs are because players get into *fights.* Don't change the topic, son. ANSWER!

[braddyboy82]

So, being "badass" per your twisted definition is: being called for tripping, cross checking, unsportsmanlike conduct, and hooking??

[braddyboy82]

@MrHannan1992

Carcillio has taken bad penalties that are usually not fighting related. The stats prove this conclusively.

Are you new to hockey? Fighting majors generally cancel each other out. You have statistically proven that Carcillo leaves his team short handed; thus he takes dumb minors for the majority of his PIM.

Ah, I am being mean with all my facts? OK: how many goals has Carcillo scored this season?? How many PIM does he have this season??

Look at Parros stats.

I rest my case.

[MrHannan1992]

@braddyboy82 PIM doesn't equate fighting or enforcing? Avery still fought 7 times. If he never fought at all, then I could understand what you are saying, but Avery still fights. 100% of the time, if a person has over 100 PIM, they have fought. You find me one example going against this and you would have broken me down. But PIM does equate fighting. If you have near league leading PIM, you have some amount of fighting majors.

Carcillo has lead the league in PIM past years because of hooking?

[MrHannan1992]

@braddyboy82 By the way. Look at the playing time. If Parros had the playing time that Avery has had, then possibly he would have around the same penalty minutes. Not from fighting, but from taking a penalty and just being on the ice more. Unfortunately, he isn't a good enough hockey player to play for more than 8 minutes a game. And I never said a single thing about this years PIM. So I don't know how I can be wrong about something I wasn't discussing.

[MrHannan1992]

@braddyboy82 Okay Parros has fought more than them, but if you see my post from earlier, you will see me write that Parros' only job is fighting, while Carcillo has more of a job than just fighting. And then I go on to write about Carcillo's points in hockey compared to Parros' which are no where near Carcillo's.

And plus, I wrote that a person will never lead the league in penalty minutes without any fighting majors. And Avery still does have fighting majors this year.

[braddyboy82]

@MrHannan1992

Sorry, you're wrong again. The facts do not lie: Avery has 127 penalty minutes this season but he's only fought 7 times. Carcillo also has only fought 7 times.

George Parros has 101 penalty minutes but has dropped the gloves *17* times. That means out of George's 101 penalty minutes this season, 85 of them were from fighting majors.

Conclusion: PIM does not equate fighting nor enforcing.

Thanks for playing, come back when you join reality.