their beloved imam syafie , and imam malik, whether they have difficulties will have taken wudhu, pray near the prophet tomb and recitte doa , which include ya muhammad......so why would now ppl were so paranoid of saying the prophet name and the imam name after the gods name? see doa qunut, and our tahiyyat in our salah,.......we do invoke prayers for our prophet and his family...
yes this is because he was standing right in front of there dead bodies or their graves so they could hear him speaking, just as muhammed (s.a.w) spoke to the kuffars dead bodies after the battle of badr because they were right there in front of him so they could hear him......but when Ali (r.a) is buried in arabia and people in india, pakistan, Iran or america or wherever are saying "ya ali madad" , he cannot hear you and you are implying that he has some kind of all-hearing power.
he said ya iblis because iblis was right there in front of allah and able to hear allah, so if ali (r.a) was standing in front of you and you said ya ali, it wouldnt be shirk, but if hes passed away and you say ya ali then you're implying that ali is all-hearing and that he can hear your call somehow, even though we know that only allah is all-hearing
this is like, the shias are telling the catholics "the catholics are closer to the true Islam, because you have idols in worshiping like us (shia). unlike the protestants, they don't have any idols to worship, can you believe that?! just like the sunnie scums.".
their beloved imam syafie , and imam malik, whether they have difficulties will have taken wudhu, pray near the prophet tomb and recitte doa , which include ya muhammad......so why would now ppl were so paranoid of saying the prophet name and the imam name after the gods name? see doa qunut, and our tahiyyat in our salah,.......we do invoke prayers for our prophet and his family...
setias16 7 months ago
search for
( Sunnah Iran - Shia without Taqiah ! ) playlist
DrUnk91Bullet 2 years ago
yes this is because he was standing right in front of there dead bodies or their graves so they could hear him speaking, just as muhammed (s.a.w) spoke to the kuffars dead bodies after the battle of badr because they were right there in front of him so they could hear him......but when Ali (r.a) is buried in arabia and people in india, pakistan, Iran or america or wherever are saying "ya ali madad" , he cannot hear you and you are implying that he has some kind of all-hearing power.
vtec127 2 years ago
look at the verse 7:78--79
Quran mentions the Prophet Salih's speech to the dead. This speech was made after his nation had been destroyed.
janisar87 2 years ago
he said ya iblis because iblis was right there in front of allah and able to hear allah, so if ali (r.a) was standing in front of you and you said ya ali, it wouldnt be shirk, but if hes passed away and you say ya ali then you're implying that ali is all-hearing and that he can hear your call somehow, even though we know that only allah is all-hearing
vtec127 2 years ago 2
at 1:49 where it says only YA ALLAH..
well u cult wahabi note this quran verse where the word is being mentioned for your forfather SHITAN iblis.
It says ya iblisin quran 38:75.. If quran is mentioning that allah says o iblis..means ya iblis..
Why cant we say Ya Muhammad ? And ali and so on
thats a gr8 logic in it..
Go read the quran u WAHABI paganssss..
janisar87 2 years ago
rafidah kafir
Tigar64 3 years ago
this is like, the shias are telling the catholics "the catholics are closer to the true Islam, because you have idols in worshiping like us (shia). unlike the protestants, they don't have any idols to worship, can you believe that?! just like the sunnie scums.".
ZeriqViz 3 years ago