Magus Rebuttals: Adaptations and the Ice and Fire Adaptation

This is a rebuttal to Asands123 concerning adaptations in general and the adaptation of my favorite book series "A Song of Ice and Fire".

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Song
• of
• Ice
• and
• Fire
• HBO
• sereis
• magusx1
• Dexter
• George
• RR
• martin
• Asands123

[germaholic]

Are the song of fire and ice books standalone novels involving the same characters or do they need to be read in a certain order?

[MagusX1]

They are not stand alones, they need to be read in order. There are four books out right now only, but they are big fat books...but they are worth reading though and definetly worth checking out!

[asands123]

wow, you had a lot of nice points...ill have to make another video soon...after exams this week

annnnd i just saw Rome, the same people who are directing ASOIAF if im not mistaken, so my opnion has changed somewhat

[MagusX1]

Sure, I cannot wait to see your new video, I watched some of your other vids and you make very good points in them as well! Its always good to hear from fellow ASOIAF fans!

[justgunz3]

Are you a ranter and debater now?most of your newer videos are magus discussions and rants.i miss the anime reviews

[MagusX1]

@justgunz3 well in this vid I did state there was an anime reveiw coming! So be on the watch for that!

[Kayz1mega]

True that's very true like watchmen was a good adaptation to me even though people say its not as good at the original series I thought it did its job as a good adaptation movie.

[asands123]

im dont compain about adaptions because theyre not exactly to the book but that theyre bad in capturing the feeling of the book. im glad however that GRRM is taking an active part in the series

[some360fanboy]

Magus, bring back a few anime reviews our way! :D

[CrzyNick]

pssh books.....

I own 4 books

[Kayz1mega]

Adaptations should just be done by people who know the material and thats it because then people wont bitch about the adaptations.

[Lionheart831]

Wat up Magus, I am sorry that I didn't get the chance to see your videos lately, I had to buy a new PC tower because my old one had recently expired after 3 and the half years of having it. I know you are a busy person but I just want to see how is it going.and I wish you the best luck. Btw great video.