kata but Kancho made some small changes to make us understand better some things... I do not say that other versions are not good !! Kancho explains all these changes and why in kata..most of them has to do with bunkai and few of them has to do with breathing... oss to alla karateka out there....
In SKIF kancho Kanazawa in this kata (and also in gojushiho-dai whis is -sho in jka) the tate shuto is over arm.. This because in every kamae position it is very difficult to perform a really strong and fast block under arm.. any karateka try to do the bunkai..stand on a kamae in moto dachi,zenkutsu, kokutsu (or in any oter stance) and try to block a fast attack.. it's much more practical (power and angle of the block).. All of you know that the bunkai is not neccesary exactly as it shows on
Does anyone know why in this video he prepares for the zuki with hand over instead of under? I have searched all over utube and all other chinte kata are under arm not over arm as with shuto
0.51 if you want to check it! Sorry if I am not emplaining myself very well!!!
I agree with maotas. I think the 3 hops were added by Nakayama Sensei to end the kata at the starting position. The Okinawan version doesn't have the three hops. Anyone can create number of bunkai to any body movement. Even you just do nothing, they will tell there's a bunkai. You are concentrating and observing the opponent without any move.
@RNLarkin: We have five additional katas fro shodan, nidan and sandan. It is of course fine to learn your katas in good time, but leaning all at once is like trying to drink from a fire hydrant. :)
In my style, Shito-ryu, we learn it at 8 kyu. It is a kata we teach the students early so by the time the are shodan the have it down pretty well. Thanks for your input.
kata but Kancho made some small changes to make us understand better some things... I do not say that other versions are not good !! Kancho explains all these changes and why in kata..most of them has to do with bunkai and few of them has to do with breathing... oss to alla karateka out there....
skifhania 11 months ago
In SKIF kancho Kanazawa in this kata (and also in gojushiho-dai whis is -sho in jka) the tate shuto is over arm.. This because in every kamae position it is very difficult to perform a really strong and fast block under arm.. any karateka try to do the bunkai..stand on a kamae in moto dachi,zenkutsu, kokutsu (or in any oter stance) and try to block a fast attack.. it's much more practical (power and angle of the block).. All of you know that the bunkai is not neccesary exactly as it shows on
skifhania 11 months ago
one question when he makes the move at 0:42 is it over the shoulder...
in other vids i see people making the move under the arm...
pagondouin 1 year ago
@johnyboy1975
there are difference which can be soo tiny .. each Sensei from a SKIEF country has his own philosophy!
GermanDani 1 year ago
THANK You, Shihan! this clip is an useful lesson !!
I have started exercising Chinte!
GermanDani 1 year ago
Does anyone know why in this video he prepares for the zuki with hand over instead of under? I have searched all over utube and all other chinte kata are under arm not over arm as with shuto
0.51 if you want to check it! Sorry if I am not emplaining myself very well!!!
johnyboy1975 1 year ago
I agree with maotas. I think the 3 hops were added by Nakayama Sensei to end the kata at the starting position. The Okinawan version doesn't have the three hops. Anyone can create number of bunkai to any body movement. Even you just do nothing, they will tell there's a bunkai. You are concentrating and observing the opponent without any move.
aiko4321 2 years ago
@RNLarkin: We have five additional katas fro shodan, nidan and sandan. It is of course fine to learn your katas in good time, but leaning all at once is like trying to drink from a fire hydrant. :)
bajerfan 2 years ago
In my style, Shito-ryu, we learn it at 8 kyu. It is a kata we teach the students early so by the time the are shodan the have it down pretty well. Thanks for your input.
RNLarkin 2 years ago
@RNLarkin It is part of syllabus for sandan in SKIF.
bajerfan 2 years ago