Part 1: The Taiwan Question, Historic Mismanagement

This series of broadcasts uncovers the truth behind the US Executive Branch's Historic Mismanagement of the Taiwan question over the past half-century. Based on an examination of the laws of war, international treaty law, and US Constitutional law, a complete dissection of the complicated inter-relationship between Taiwan, the USA, and China is offered. Proceeding with a clear recognition of these legal fundamentals, the question of whether Taiwan is currently independent, or under the jurisdiction of the PRC, Japan, or some other country can be answered, and the proper direction for Taiwan's future political development quickly becomes apparent.

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• treaty
• sovereignty
• territory
• Taiwan
• cession
• Formosa
• insular
• USMG
• occupation
• Hartzell

[lisu2008]

Sorry to write so long, but I hope you can understand, China is always the suzerain of Taiwan, you can't say due to an illicit treaty, so the suzerain is Jap. Jap is not the suzerain, she can not decide to cede in 1952

[tprophet77]

Totally invalid under international law, sorry. 1895 was a valid cession to Japan, and 48 nations recognized Japan's cession as of April 28, 1952. Please stop talking nonsense. Thanks.

[lisu2008]

Ok, tprophet77, if you don't dare to face the facts, I don't need to discuss with you. But I can tell you nowadays, 160+ (far more than 48) countries insist Taiwan is a part of China, including Taiwan's constitute :)

[tprophet77]

You are the one who is not facing the facts. Taiwan was ceded by Japan in the peace treaty of April 28, 1952. That was fully recognized under international law. China was not the "receiving country." Stop arguing nonsense.

[lisu2008]

but there is not only one international treaty -SFPT, right? Not to mention Japan didn't cede Taiwan in SFPT. She simply gave up all her rights on Taiwan. 1972, in another treaty signed by China and Japan, Japan insist obeying Cario and Postdam Declarations: return Taiwan to her suzerain - China

[tprophet77]

There was no 1972 treaty. You are making things up. Cairo and Potsdam are of less legal weight than SFPT. Taiwan was ceded in SFPT Article 2b. Your Chinese propaganda is childish.

[zzztop105]

from this notice, one can figure that there are a lots of complaints about chinese tourists and they don't behave. That's why they have to be reminded over and over just like a kid.

[Frankfurter8888]

If Taiwan is a part of China, why China likes to threaten Taiwan with more than 1300 missiles? Chinese always tell me about their love for Taiwan - sounds more like rape than love.

[peak9Y01]

不服氣的，看這裡：

sites.ｇｏｏｇｌｅ.com/site/dawamank­ali/da-he-wan-ren

[IronJackalTw]

AMERICA likes to blame CHINA as the BAD GUY, but why is USA still supporting the ONE CHINA POLICY!? People out there needs to understand that TAIWAN is the Secret Colonial State of America!

After WW2 when America defeated Japan, did USA gave Taiwanese People the freedom to elect our Taiwanese Government? No, they did not! What they did instead is to install an USA PUPPET Government by the name of KMT!

This is starts of American Imperalism of TAIWAN!

[chinaflagforum]

thats good for you, but u are now an american, not a taiwanese, different nationality

[rsonbie456]

asshole! Im from taiwan but i cant read alot of chinese either...because we are USA taiwanese. Of course we are learning how to READ chinese...i only know how to speak it

[chinaflagforum]

Note: im friendly with most Japanese people except for scumbag like you, stop disgracing the Japanese people, Japanese people dont need people like you to insult others

祝你好自為之，KakimotoRift先生，（如果你看得懂中­文的話）呵呵，也請你老實一點，日本出身就日本出身，還什么臺灣­國出身呢，臺灣出身還不會看中文，假不假啊？

[chinaflagforum]

please, stop pretending to be someone else, your making a fool of your self, and think before you comment

"u stated in ur blog u like Mao"

lol where? can you copy and paste it here?

can you even read traditional chinese? i doubt it

[chinaflagforum]

you chinese dog, chinese slave. Be gone!

nobody likes china~

china should be gone~

eliminate china~

in ur blog u said u like Mao.

You fool~

lol~

lol,is that what you can say, i feel pity foir you, my japanese friend, most of the ppl on my channel are from taiwan and they all promote confucius teaching with me, i'll just invite them to have a look at your channel to see how fake can you be

[chinaflagforum]

in your Channel, u said your from Taiwan, but you couldnt even read traditional Chinese, hm.......something funny here

[chinaflagforum]

lol, please copy and paste the verse where i said it, if you can read Chinese

what you said really made you look stupid

my Channel actually condem CCP and promote confucius teaching, how pity

and i havent even said anything offensive against Japan, very disappointed with you, my japanese friend, your a shame of ur nation

[KakimotoRift]

The truth about Taiwan's status is that Taiwan is an independent country for a long time.

You don't need to call lovely Japanese in such a way.

Japan did not plan to or has a mind of taking over Taiwan or invading Taiwan.

china is the asshole that is trying to invade Taiwan and take over Taiwan by force illegally. But still~ china does not dare declare a war against Taiwan. Too bad~ Dream on will you? chinese slaves~