Bach to the Future: Jesu, Joy of Man's Desiring
Top Comments
All Comments (94)
-
awful! Stay of of bach!
-
brilliantly arranged!
-
@PaulinaPaulino I always squirm a little when people speak for someone who is dead. I am a major supporter of remakes, punk remakes of old standards are among my favorite songs. This is just a terrible arrangement in my opinion. You can argue that if you want, but I won't be here for it.
-
@cnoyes82 Bach was first and foremost a teacher. Das Wohltemperierte Klavier was in effect a songbook for students to understand all the different scales. He would have encouraged his students to make adaptations of 'old classics'. Personally, I think he would be thrilled with this wonderful arrangement.
-
@cnoyes82 After having some more time and listening to it again, I actually think it's more accurate to say it sounds like Phish remade "Jesu Joy of Man's Desiring" and then this band remade the Phish version.
-
It's funny, if someone were to remake a beautiful classical painting in graffiti and call it art people would be up in arms, but turning one of Bach's best works into a Christmas Jingle is somehow higher art. I don't know how anyone can hear this and think "wow, what a great rendition". I hear it and wonder how many wasted hours went into its arrangement.
-
The magic of Bach is in the notes, not so much the sound timbres --- so it always seems to be fine, regardless of the instrumentation. Such universal music.
-
@MyPasswordisGrawp In fact they should play it on the radios during the holiday season, that would be way cool.
Diferent but good. I prefer the original of corse. But its always good to see diferents and good arrangements
leolinklima 2 years ago 9
It sounds more like a jig
BayAreaBiker2001 3 years ago 5