Carly Smithson - Crazy On You - Top 20
Top Comments
All Comments (34)
-
I hated how they sabotaged Carly and Syesha...they were definitely finale-worthy if not top 3.
-
Not that I followed it much to begin with, but I completely quit watching at all after Carly was booted off. What a bunch of popularity contest BS! Simon Cowell is so fortunate to have a job. What the heck has HE ever done? Great performance!
-
her pitch!!!! amazing!
-
AMAZING!!!!!!!
-
she sings heart really good! she is just amazing
-
@jrw0305 I agree, I think it was the first time a non-American was by far the most talented vocalist and deserved to win, but after all...it is American Idol and that might not be completely good for the producers.
-
@jrw0305 : In the second verse, on the word sang, in "I sang you a song I heard up above" was sharp. Also, the word crazy, in the second "crazy on you" was flat a quarter pitch.
Also, he was a bit raspy at the end when she was belting.
Otherwise, nice overall vocal quality, and I like her whole tone.
-
Love her from Costa Rica...!!
-
This gal is grand!!!!!!!!
-
great she has every single abilty that should of make her winn
ok so this was when i officially lost respect for randy jackson. there was absolutely nothing pitchy about this WHATSOEVER. clearly the producers decided to throw carly under the bus, and this was where it started...
jrw0305 3 years ago 50
she's absolutely amazing!!! totally should have won
GO IRELAND!!!!!!
Bookworm246579 2 years ago 29