Joyce DiDonato sings Rinaldo - Venti turbini - Handel
Uploader Comments (thecelticspirit)
Top Comments
-
she would be the PERFECT Rinaldo!!!
but this is way to fast...
All Comments (23)
-
Just compare this to David Daniels and one can hear that Rinaldo does not sound right in a feminine voice. Fast notes sound off to me tuning wise. Something not quite right here.
-
Beaucoup trop vite - ridicule !
-
@MrMarcvus But in Handel's time it was common for mezzos to sing the male parts originally intended for castrati if none were available (or if the composer wanted one), and for castrati to sing female parts at times. This is authentic! It should also be remembered that we can't know if castrati sounded like either mezzos or countertenors, so in the absence of a genuine castrato, both can get away with singing this kind of material. While I love me some countertenor, both have something to offer!
-
I wish women would leave the Castrati/counter tenor arias alone they have a very different sound and were only rarely used in the opera of that period. as a Counter tenor I would not touch any soprano arias leave the male arias alone. It is like a flute playing recorder music does not sound right.
-
the violin is like a squeaking squealing cassette tape gone bad. hahahahaha I know the effect trying to be done here.... but it didn't work.
-
This is the kind of force I feel many renditions of this song lack. RInaldo is MAD, after all! Joyce Didonato tore this aria up - it's a damn shame the poor instrumentalists were given such an absurd tempo...
-
Poor Haendel, poor Joyce, fucking violin
-
the instrumentalist was horrible...Joyce was Perfect!!!!
-
did the instrumentalists have to pee? so sloppy! Joyce was fabulous as ALWAYS though.
-
belíssimo!!!!bravo
not a video, alas - shot in Salzburg or someplace?
too fast and the playing is messy, but the singing certainly isn't! Go Yankee Diva
jeepgerhard212 2 years ago 9
From my description: November 30th, 2007, Théâtre des Champs Élysées.
thecelticspirit 2 years ago
sorry, i assumed you meant the PHOTO was from TDC, which it isn't: it's from last summer after she broke her leg (see crutch on floor next to her?)!
My mistake. THANKS FOR THE POST!!! Their playing is still messy but v exciting and JDid is fab, always (just saw her Rosina in Los Angeles)
jeepgerhard212 2 years ago
Yep, I know, just a few random pics of some of her concerts, because I couldn't find any about this specific concert. The photo from Salzburg is amazing, imo :)
And you're very welcome! You saw her in LA? Gosh, you're so lucky! I'm a little bit to far to fly over there, but I definitely have to go and see her as Rosina someday. Just thinking about what she did with her wheelchair makes drop my jaw. She's amazing!
thecelticspirit 2 years ago
Aaaaaaaaaaaah! I've loved this aria since I heard it in Farinelli <3<3<3<3
Lilith89ibz 2 years ago
though I don't remember this aria ves'
thecelticspirit 2 years ago