Aimi Kobayashi - Chopin Piano Concerto #1 op.11 E-minor - 1st movement
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (30)
-
@existentialist18 Of course Rubinstein's performance is better! Why on earth would you feel the need to compare a 15-year-old to Rubinstein? I'm sure Rubinstein's own performances at age 15 wouldn't stand up to comparison with his mature work. That doesn't change the fact that this is a genuinely felt performance, as I'm sure you would believe if the picture were replaced with that of a European male.
At any rate, Aimi is wonderful as always here!
-
I am slightly confused. On the one hand this is absolutely wonderful, on the other, there's something not quite right with the notion of wunderkinder in the 21st century. Perhaps pacing life a little more naturally is not a bad idea to ensure a long, happy, creative life that has some poetic value. Want to write bravo here, but mustn't. My daughter's (1yr old) first piano lesson: 2016. As for playing Chopin, she has to fall in love first.
-
@stanhin "When you overpractice, the music seems to come out of your pocket. If you play with a feeling of 'Oh, I know this,' you play without that drop of fresh blood that is necessary. At every concert I must have the unexpected, the unforeseen. I want to risk, to dare. I want to be surprised. That way the music can bloom anew. The act is the same, but each time it's different."-Rubinstein. Or, if you're more into this type of performance, I can pop you some popcorn and you can enjoy the act.
-
@existentialist18 wrote: "I hate to say it." Good because the rest is bs.
-
A littler girl but a great pianist.
-
그냥 대박!!
너무 좋아하는곡인데 ㅎㅎ
진짜 멋져요
-
小林愛実ちゃんの演奏のどこかに、若いのと音楽は関係ないと書い
てあったが、確かにその通りではある。若いのと音楽はごちゃまぜ にしてはならないし、彼女もそんな評価は望んでいないだろう。 しかし、この若さで大曲もしっかり解釈し自分の音楽にし表現して
いるところは本当に素晴らしい。 できそうでできないことです。
大人になってやっと解釈でき表現できるってこともあります。
タッチも素晴らしい、そして若いから出せるのかもしれませんが、
彼女の音は本当に美しい音です。
-
@concerto35: She could do it when she was 5. She can do it because, as you say, she transcends the notes (material), becoming music itself (spirit).
-
I hate to say it, but I don't think there is that much emotion in it at all. I much prefer seeing a 80 something year old Rubinstein pour years of life into his piece; something that just can't be compensated for at that age. She is very talented, but it's just not the same.
-
great youth orchestra!!
Aimi infuses every note with pathos. She addresses the heart, and in listening to her, one becames enraptured in an estatic conversation. She transcends the notes themselves, enveloping one in an experience of mystical contemplation. How can she do this at only 15 years? It is a gift from God held in trust by Aimi for the world.
concerto35 7 months ago 8
Voici une belle initiative ma chair Christina. C'est vraiment un plaisir de te savoir présente sur ce média pour continuer à diffuser l'excellence de notre princesse Aimi kobayashi. Les archives et les nombreuses performances nous pourront les entendre et voir sur ta chaîne. Alors chair Christina merci pour le partage...
jacques de paris
lepaintre123 7 months ago 6