Liszt - Au bord d'une source (Cecile Licad, 2002)
Top Comments
All Comments (12)
-
:D
-
A meditative, reflective, rather wistful reflection on a gentle, trickling spring. Very lovely in its own way.
I do prefer Horowitz's more energetic, refreshing view of a younger more more forceful kind of spring, but that may be because I have been used to it for sixty years.
Cécile Licad is an artist of the highest rank. I love and respect all her playing, and enjoyed this alternative view of Au bord ... immensely.
-
I do hear imitations of flowing and falling water, and undulation of landscape in Liszt's piano writing here. That does color my conception. It's true that his first of 2 versions are generally denser (well, the etudes have 3), but I don't know the first of Au bord, Do you know where her unusual readings in a couple of spots come from? I've never heard them before. Is there an alternate version? By the way, I like her interpretation the more I hear it! Peace to you and yours.
-
Interpretation is a personal thing. I shouldn't have blankly said what I did. I did acknowledge that others love her performance. She is a fine pianist. I just differ in my own conception. Actually, my comments might be expected from one who does play the piece. I posted it here (shortly before I heard Licad) though it was recorded on my computer's microphone. I hope you like it, though it may be too straightforward for your taste.
-
Too much rubato. A spring flows smoothly, whether it is a trickle or a torrent. Interesting text, with some unusual notes. Is this the first version??? Must be. I do like Cecile Licad, but she's got this one wrong. But others love her playing here, so it's just me. And that's a good thing.
-
quiet is better in this piece, chases away the demons that can be found in much of liszt's music, fine performance, "see a landscape in my head that is like a fine poussin,seeming small yet large.
-
Very nice. I love your interpretation!
Do you play this piece? Considering your remarks, I think not. This is not the first version, which would sound more like an ocean on a modern piano . It is "By a Spring" not "A Spring". The spring would be one in the Swiss Alps but the piece is not about the spring. I do play this piece and I think that Licad plays it wonderfully. If you played it, you would be appreciate her consumate artistry much more. It is tremendously tricky to pull off. The rubato is perfect.
grdiii 3 years ago 4
danbar 73
A wonderful lyrical Liszt. Bravo!!! Thanks for posting.
danbar73 4 years ago 3