This piece was lost the moment it started, Spirituality is required !!!, this version is hard driving,& too fast,with no sense of Piety, Gentleness or soft Grace,-However I do Love P'J's voice,but the conductor did not match the music to the Text ! Absolutely no question about it.
I have spent time living in a Franciscan Monastery,(Silent Order)&the Overwhelming sense of Holiness & Godliness must be felt.Philippe has it but sadly it was overplayed by the Band.
I am a devoted fan of Phillipe, but I do prefer Michael Chance's voice in this piece. I am so glad Phillipe is coming to Poland :) I am going to listen to him in real at last.
Es mucho mejor el de Andreas Scholl, la música de Bach no requiere esa brillantez, i la voz de Scholl es mucho mas limpia y afinada. Además creo que el vibrato es muy exagerado en los finales de frase.
Sin dudarlo me quedo con la version de Andreas Scholl, creo que es el contratenor perfecto para cantar Bach.
This piece was lost the moment it started, Spirituality is required !!!, this version is hard driving,& too fast,with no sense of Piety, Gentleness or soft Grace,-However I do Love P'J's voice,but the conductor did not match the music to the Text ! Absolutely no question about it.
I have spent time living in a Franciscan Monastery,(Silent Order)&the Overwhelming sense of Holiness & Godliness must be felt.Philippe has it but sadly it was overplayed by the Band.
Atmosfferic 4 days ago
J'ai écouté nombre de versions, et mes preferées sont, dans l'ordre décroissant: DELLER, STUTZMANN, SCHOLL, DANIELS, et JARROUSKY;;
Pour l'impact émotionnel, Deller surtout, et Stutzmann m'on fait pleurer!!!
ladomi7962 2 weeks ago
Lindo!
Paz e Bem!!!
CristaoCatolico07 1 month ago
meraviglioso!
redhotpg 2 months ago
I am a devoted fan of Phillipe, but I do prefer Michael Chance's voice in this piece. I am so glad Phillipe is coming to Poland :) I am going to listen to him in real at last.
SweeetKiss 3 months ago
Je regrette presque d'avoir écouté Andreas Scholl en premier. Je n'arrive pas à apprecier d'autres interpretations.
no38no 5 months ago
i like Alfreds Dellers interpretation more..
this one is too fast and too forcefull
wiwq 6 months ago
Difficile de faire mieux apres Alfred Deller! Il faut croire que les messes ne sied pas a Jaroussky trop "lumineux"
MrYanntokyo 6 months ago
@olympina Agreed. Skill without soul.
FrauShai 6 months ago
Es mucho mejor el de Andreas Scholl, la música de Bach no requiere esa brillantez, i la voz de Scholl es mucho mas limpia y afinada. Además creo que el vibrato es muy exagerado en los finales de frase.
Sin dudarlo me quedo con la version de Andreas Scholl, creo que es el contratenor perfecto para cantar Bach.
fortega91 1 year ago