Moonshiner
Uploader Comments (lamancuso12)
Top Comments
-
That's Roscoe Holcomb
-
I agree----Unfortunately for us folks in the mountains, Mr. Zimmerman did not give us much credit for a number of traditional songs he covered.
All Comments (46)
-
I agree my family is from the smokey mtns and this video seems a little offensive to me.Of course,as an intelligent individual you have to consider that for people who arent like us and didnt grow up like us and dont live a life like ours it is more of a romantic thought.Roscoe was singing more about the perspective of an outsider than himself.Anyone who knows,knows that he was happily married and didnt make moonshine.He was a miner and later a musician.Video stupid,song awesome!
-
Beautifully filmed!
-
Love this song. Bob Dylan's version is also very beautiful.
-
Beautiful
-
Hi from france .... (bad english sorry)
I'am not american and i never dig some coal as Roscoe Holcomb ... but ...
Les chansons de R.Holcomb sont incroyables ... elle s'ecoutent avec l'ame et le coeur ... Great Great Great ^^
-
@kattoy06 so sweetly like good ole moonshine sorry for all the spelling erros
-
@kattoy06 i have been a moon shiner ever since that i been born i drunk up all of my money and stilled up all of my corn ill go up some dark hallow and put up my moonshine still it will make you 1 gallon for a five dollar bill ill go up some dark hallow and get you some boose if the revenews dont get me no money then i loose come on all you moon shiners stand all in a row your looks so sad and lonsome your lonsome yes i know god bless them prity women i wish they all were mine there breath smell
-
@lamancuso12 the dylan version has a few diffrent lyics but just about the same
-
Hey Buck! Yes, I like this video.
But, you will never be this real.
Lillie
Anyone know the lyrics, or know where to find them online?
kattoy06 2 years ago
Type in Moonshiner Lyrics into google, you get a lot. The bob dylan version is word for word I believe. I'd post them on here but there's a word count limit.
lamancuso12 2 years ago
Where there's smoke...
lamancuso12 3 years ago
Thank you for your responses
lamancuso12 4 years ago
I like the music, of course, but I don't think Mr. Holcomb would have liked the connotation of the video. People made moonshine in these mountains to make a better life for their families and for themselves . . . they didn't do it to get laid. This video sheds a negative light on Appalachian folk-culture as I live it and know it. However, an intelligent person would know that the music means so much more than this silly video.
chriscasbarro 4 years ago
I appreciate your experience with moonshining , but take into account the lyrics. Roscoe sings about the loneliness of his trade and about alcoholism. He romanticizes it: "God bless them all them pretty women, I wish they all were mine/ their breath smells so sweetly like that good old moonshine". Roscoe isn't singing about making a living or making a better life. He's singing a life dependent on alcohol, making it and consuming it.
And that is what the video makes relevant.
lamancuso12 4 years ago 4