Carly Season 5 audition in Vegas

Carly Hennesy's season 5 American idol audition, had she gotten her papers handled, she woulda been part of the show's best season ever.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• carly
• hennesy
• smithson
• season
• five
• american
• idol

[DyingGrassPriest]

between all this Carly and Amy bickering, i think we are all straying away from the real problem... JUSTIN BIEBER!!!!!

[12345carlyfan]

Carly sounds awesome here. Can't wait for the We Are The Fallen album so we can hear more of her voice.

[Chris201076]

WOW I spent YEARS looking for this, thank you SO MUCH

[claus49]

OMG she was much better back then

[idoltyler06]

It would've been interesting to see her compete this season. I bet you Taylor would've been gone, or instead of Katherine in Taylor, it would've been Katherine and Carly, or Chris and Carly, or Elliot and Carly, or meh taylor and CARLY!! But she got the cooler stage in season 7, and she got the beatles!

[TiaVampire]

Amy could never do that.

[BridgetteMidgette]

Amy sings great live. So does Carly. I think Amy is better, but hey, Im not gonna bash Carly, shes great too. shes not copying Amy. Theyre both original rock singers. I really wish all the EV fans would respect Amy and just not compare the bands. And the same with the Carly fans. Please please, both of the sides just. chill out. Oh and they have covered a bunch of EV songs. but hey, half the band is ex-EV members, so theyre not really copying them, js. dont hate Carly or Amy.

[pete2k10]

@moyle1353 CARLY ISN'T A FUCKING GOD you delusional fuck. She sucks live too a lot of the times. GET YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR ASS. I don't care if people listen, cause I'm shoving it down their throats anyway like currently I am to you.

[moyle1353]

@paranormalrockstar Lol, her looks? big freakin woop, she has black hair, pale skin, and beautiful eyes. So she has a goth style, doesn't mean she's going "Amy Lee" I love Amy and Carly, just because they are both beautiful gothic rock singers and Amy came before Carly doesn't mean a thing! It's like people say Amy is copying Sharen (from Within Temptation) just because she came before Amy/...

[moyle1353]

@pete2k10 erm...for the most part, Ben wrote and arranged alot of their hits, so don't hate on We Are The Fallen, Carly isn't an Amy, and you and I both know Amy can hardly sing live, unless she works out her voice...Where as Carly is 100% actual voice.....and also Ben left Evanescence so Carly didn't have anything to do with him leaving....and also mind letting off on the ''caps lock'' key? It may make people say hey, your mature, I think I'll listen to you..

[pete2k10]

@rparker91 I THINK I AM UP FOR THE CHALLENGE MISTER.

[rparker91]

@pete2k10 Oh, I don't know if I could help you to understand. It'd take years for someone like you to learn how to do something so difficult.