Astrid Varnay als Elektra (Köln 1953)
Uploader Comments (SDCmorg)
Top Comments
-
Thank you not only for your postings but for your comments, too. Unfortunately we can read not only wise commentary here and I fully agree with the nonsense in finding the best diva in the certain aria. What a flat aproach toward dramatic art in general! I profer Igne Borkh as Elektra but it would never restrict me to enjoy another artist /and Astrid Varnay is one of them/.
-
yes, it is my favorite "Elektra". Varnay is a goddess, and I think that Kraus' conducting is more interesting than Solti's. Not so hectic but just therefore more expressive. So german :)
All Comments (16)
-
Besides all other qualities of this performance, I did not think Elektra could be sung with such clear diction!
-
My heart always belongs to Birgit, but boy, this is fantastic too.
-
Really, really the elektra to end all elektras. This is better than the met one from the previous year. And to have seen her in action must have been exhilarating! She was the complete lyric-acting-soprano. She had everything. That lucious middle voice and piercing high notes.
-
They are both great! Varneay had a great deal more in the middle, and those voices sometimes don't have the ease in the higher tones... Nilsson had the tops like made, but never the lush soud on the middle voice. Both wonderful in the role. Thank for for both of them. Thank God for Borkh as well, She was also wonderful.
-
Brilliant singing from a brilliant singer. If I am allowed I'd say I love Nilssons more because of her focused brilliance that made Electra sound somewhat colder and therefore more scary to me. I can only hope I'll be fortunate enough to sing it myself one day in the not too vast future, when I grow up. Till then I'll just enjoy all the fantastic singers that are and that have been entertaining and doing their absolute best to move us. Viva Richard Strauss!!! May he live on through his music.
-
Fast überflüssig den Text anzuführen, da die Varnay hier unglaublich wortdeutlich ist!
-
My absolute favorite performance of this amazing monologue, Varnay was a consummate vocal actress along the lines of Callas. The sound here is excellent, better than my CDs; many thanks for uploading it.
-
This is abslutely true! Her acting and dramatic singing is similar to Callas`s. This is what I wanted to express above... Hardly some artist can be generaly said to be the best of all. But there are certain roles in which one can be unsurpassable. And Varnay`s Kostelnicka is real dramatic art lesson!! Thank a lot fot the clip!
Thanks for comments, guys. :o) I'll ask for restraint in projecting which diva sings this thing 'better'. They are all different artists and bring different qualities to their interpretation. I'll take Varnay's 1953 Elektra if I'm only allowed one, but that doesn't mean she was better than anyone else. I just prefer her way of acting with her voice. Nilsson and Varnay were good friends and they appreciated each other.
SDCmorg 3 years ago
Wow, what an expressive voice! Though I'm not a fan of Srauss' music and never heard this opera, I can very well imagine what a gorgeous Elektra Varnay had been.
Arashi110 4 years ago 2
She was probably the most unforgettable Elektra, I think. She was the Maria Callas of the German opera after WW II years. You really must look for her clips as the Kostelnicka in Jenufa. She has me silently shrieking for mercy as she runs off the stage with the baby every time I watch it.
It's a real shame no video exist of her in her Soprano yrs. Would love to see her Bruennhilde, Fidelio, and Isolde. :o) I didn't like Elektra until I heard this CD, then the opera suddenly isn't long enough!
SDCmorg 4 years ago