VAUGHAN WILLIAMS - Symphony No 5 in D (3rd movement)
Uploader Comments (door2yourheart)
Top Comments
-
This is just the most incredible music. Just listen and imagine any English landscape. I can see Glastonbury Tor, the South Downs, Box Hill, the Lake District, all in an instant.
All Comments (62)
-
music that makes you swallow hard as your eyes moisten
-
This is the music VW's friend, George Buterworth, might have written, had he survived the Great War--he was would have come back chastized, his ideals shattered--like VW.
-
@nomorepinkowls I love Aaron, but he was dead on wrong there.
-
@hedgehogdude123 Same here! This is my favourite movement :)
-
I am studying this piece of music for my Music A level and i must say it is a privilege to be able to study something so beautiful
-
@nomorepinkow Was Copland really that stupid?
-
@nomorepinkowls What else he could say when he wrote so much music for cow-boys.
-
@door2yourheart Both of the works and their composers are wonderful. It is a pity Copland didn't understand this work or just didn't like it, but how about if we don't sink to his momentary lapse of taste or unfortunate animal comparisons?
-
@nomorepinkowls It's a comment that has been made about the Third Symphony ('Pastoral' - the title explains the joke), and if I recall, it wasn't Copland's, but a famous (at the time) British musical critic's. But it's possible that Copland made a similar remark.
That being said, if find the Third even more extraordinary a piece than the Fifth. I don't think anything from Copland can rival with it, even though I truly love his 'Billy the Kid'.
Blimey, I'm moved and enthralled by the music and at 1:09 is Ennerdale Water, West Cumbria. We have holidayed there many times. Thankyou !
richardkelltoolmaker 1 year ago
@richardkelltoolmaker Thanks Richard, you are a man of taste! I have stayed, camped, fell walked, just walked, fished most of Cumbria. That area, Ennerdale, Lorton Vale is a haven of peace and pastoral sublimity.
door2yourheart 1 year ago
Aaron Copland, on listening to Ralph Vaughan Williams' Fifth Symphony: Like staring at a cow for forty-five minutes.
nomorepinkowls 1 year ago
@nomorepinkowls Appalachian Spring is pretty much along the same lines, just far more simplistic, and possibly with a hog rather than a cow.
door2yourheart 1 year ago
Thanks for uploading this movement. For
me RVWs 5th remains his greatest and most perfect single achievement.
lewars1912 2 years ago 4
Thank you for your kind comments lewars1912. I agree, the 5th is so sublime and also so poignant for that time of extreme conflict.
Yes, i'm not happy with the sound quality, and i keep promising myself to post a less image cluttered version so that the music will shine more. i.e. less pic bytes, more sound bytes!
door2yourheart 2 years ago