YouTube home Comedy Week on YouTube
Upload

John Weldon's "To Be"

steveasat2 steveasat2·21 videos
46
76,781
Like     Dislike 66

Sign in to YouTube

Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to like steveasat2's video.

Sign in to YouTube

Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to dislike steveasat2's video.

Sign in to YouTube

Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to add steveasat2's video to your playlist.

Uploaded on Aug 25, 2008

Canadian animation by John Weldon offering a lighthearted overview of a central problem of ontology: the continuity of existence.

Loading icon Loading...

Loading icon Loading...

Loading icon Loading...

The interactive transcript could not be loaded.

Loading icon Loading...

Loading icon Loading...

Ratings have been disabled for this video.
Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.

Uploader Comments (steveasat2)

  • riceisdelicious

    Wait... Instead of using it to teleport people which will kill the original or leave two of the person, why not just turn off the "destroy" part and then just use it to make copies of food and other supplies instead of people? It could instantly solve the huge problems like world hunger, poverty, etc.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate riceisdelicious's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate riceisdelicious's comment.
  • steveasat2

    That kind of logic is known as "Cut Lex Luthor a Check" on TVTropes. Mad scientists seem to be woefully incapable of thinking outside the box. A teleporter with the destroy function disabled would also allow us to make backup copies of ourselves before bedtime. IRL save states!

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.
    in reply to riceisdelicious (Show the comment)
  • shane borgeson

    why would she say he wanted her to be the first person to try it out if she already saw one guy try the transporter box before her. is she saying that the first guy wasn't human? that would be pretty mean if thats the case. cuz he is human.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate shane borgeson's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate shane borgeson's comment.
  • steveasat2

    "One of the first". Medallion Guy is evidently a shill, a confederate of the scientist waiting in the crowd in case no one else dares to volunteer. In which case, he's a plant as well as a human, LOL.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.
    in reply to shane borgeson (Show the comment)

Top Comments

  • john weldon

    Nice to see folks still mulling over this one; I made it around 1989, apparently several philosophy profs use it in their classes. Stephen G, sorry about the observers; just too lazy to keep drawing them all! Drop by my channel if you want to see some of what I've been up to lately.

    · 24

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate john weldon's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate john weldon's comment.
  • steveasat2

    The reasoning is based on the strong probability that entropy will increase rather than decrease whenever a facsimile is made and that this will render the copy less efficient than the original. The likelihood of an exact duplicate is extremely small, since they cannot both occupy the same space at the same time and are therefore subject to slightly different local effects. Also, it's a cartoon.

    · 20

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.
    in reply to DaleIsWigging (Show the comment)

Video Responses


All Comments (355)

Sign in now to post a comment!
  • steveasat2

    Both the original and the copy remember climbing out of a booth. If they weren't paying close attention, they could easily both believe they'd climbed out of the first booth and thus were the original.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate steveasat2's comment.
    in reply to 3Sciencenut (Show the comment)
  • 3Sciencenut

    What I don't understand is what the argument is about the "original." Obviously the 'actual' original is lying in order to save his life, but each one knows exactly which they are. The first has no memory of existing within the second booth (at least at that instance).

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate 3Sciencenut's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate 3Sciencenut's comment.
    in reply to steveasat2 (Show the comment)
  • Nif3

    Jesus fucking christ that was very fucked up, what the fuck.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate Nif3's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate Nif3's comment.
    in playlist Oh Canada
  • Burkhart4192

    I assumed that she waited until after the show ended before asking to know how it worked.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate Burkhart4192's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate Burkhart4192's comment.
    in reply to john weldon (Show the comment)
  • whitegrant

    I saw this quite a long time ago and have always remembered it, glad to have found it again

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate whitegrant's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate whitegrant's comment.
  • Burkhart4192

    My two cents - assuming that there is no way for the users to know which booth they are in, while they are in the booths they are essentially the same person with two bodies, as they are receiving identical stimuli. Thus, being destroyed and recreated is no different to the universe being destroyed and rebuilt every tick of the universe. What WAS wrong was letting out the original, as this diverged his mind from the other and made him a unique sentient individual.

    ·

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate Burkhart4192's comment.

    Sign in to YouTube

    Sign in with your YouTube Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to rate Burkhart4192's comment.
  • Loading comment...
Loading...
Loading...
Working...
Sign in to add this to Watch Later