David Sylvian - The Rabbit Skinner (Manafon, 2009)
Uploader Comments (bulucette)
Top Comments
-
Behind him now are bombastic synthesizers and distorted guitars, behind all of us. A tired sound replaced by something alien and difficult which by the comments in this page display clearly the intention of David to test his listener.
This is David Sylvian the Artist moving forward, sculpting a sound not heard on many records, stop looking for 80s David and accept the aging man coming to terms with his own mortality through bleak sonicscapes.
Video Responses
All Comments (62)
-
Have to disagree. After Blemish this (Manofon) is a massive disappointment.
-
es más duro de tragar que una piedra
-
would it hurt him to record something with a tune , been a japan fan since 1980 and still love them but this solo stuff from dave i just cant get ,sorry folks,,,,no wonder they dont sell many ,,and this is coming from one of japans biggest ever fans,,i know hes not japan anymore and cant be with mick r.i.p but something on the lines of brilliant trees would be a welcome treat to all his fans
-
so good. time for a bit of tonality though.
-
@USSCaprica - I like to think of the "discordance" a strange 'assonance' sort of italicising David's warm, buttery vocals - I must have listened to this song 100+ times since I posted that first comment of mine, everything you hear on Manafon now sounds natural and and in its place, so to speak, everything David Sylvian will ever do after Manafon will be judged intensely by those learned of this record of his; I still think he's more relevant now than ever; and I'm still enchanted after 20 years
-
@SixOneCynic Sadly you are right... the problem is that David the Artist is producing... what exactly? you tell me what you hear in this....? what you term as bleak sonicscapes is an arty way of exusing tuneless experts, discordant instruments plonking away in the background overlayed with David's brilliant vocals that really don't do or go in any particular direction. I guess it all depends on what you look for in music... if you are looking for a tune, this is not it.
-
It's a toss up between Mr Sylvian & Scott Walker...And the biggest tosser is...LOL...they're both wonderful artists...
-
Art is a lie that makes us realize the truth...
-
I adore Sylvian, but find the album Manafon an extremely difficult lesson.. and I get on with Blemish very well !! You definitely have to listen to this on headphones and in peace... maybe a bit like Mark Hollis' solo album I'd say.
...so you put the Paci's phenomenology of the negative not only in your books, mi querida amiga...
TheCinemage 2 years ago 9
I think the whole Manafon is a work of Phenomenology. I mean, the eidetic science of consciousness of Husserl and Paci...
bulucette 2 years ago 5
Video magnifico....splendido Sylvian
nightporter2005 2 years ago 2
l'intero Manafon è spettacolare.
grazie
bulucette 2 years ago
the video is perfect for the song.
BRAVO BRAVISSIMO
J.
MrJcocteau 2 years ago 5
always too much generous.
Thanks
bulucette 2 years ago