Shankar Jaikishan Night 1970 Part VIII
Top Comments
All Comments (39)
-
isnt the person on the accordion Goody Servai - the great artiste
-
Shankar's.
-
@HumanFrailtz - one has to accept that it is difficult to keep on producing fantastic songs that appeals to everybody all of the time. Having said this I can recall many films where all of their songs were wonderful. Taj Mahal, Saranga, Andaz, Bees Saal Baad, Barsaat Ki Raat, Dil Hi To Hai, Ek Phool Char Kante and the one you mention Baiju Bawra to list a few as examples. Therefore ALL MDs & Poets should be given credit for giving us many hours of happy listening.
-
SJ were much more than adapting foreign songs which they only did once or twice. In my opinion they were much more consistent than SD Burman, Naushad and C. Ramachandra (my other favorites) and the other music directors. Burman sometimes had filler songs that weren't as great as the really outstanding tracks in his soundtracks, Naushad did genius work with Baiju Bawra, Anmol Ghadi, Anokhi Aada, etc. but his later work isn't as good. C. Ramchandra is wonderful but he seems to have limited range.
-
@HumanFrailtz there is no such thing as untouchable. Sure some have directors have been very innovative such as Roshan (with Sahir's poetry) who brought quawwalis to films, SD Burman & Hemantji who gave us Hindi compositions that they created originally in Bengali etc. Whereas SK were good (and not the only ones) at taking foreign music/songs and adapting to Hindi versions. They were all great artists and to single out one above the others is pure arrogance and shows a lack of impartiality.
-
Sharda
-
@nushrah Sharda.
-
@studer3500 SD Burman, Naushad, Roshan, Salil, C. Ramchandra -- and others like Sajjad Hussein, Madan Mohan, etc. were great but Shankar Jaikishan are untouchable. Maybe SD and Naushad but not anyone else.
-
Samnukhanand Hall is biggest in mumbai, Rafi's voice doen't get b bit low. He was the greatest
-
who is the lady singer??
rafi the greatest human in film industry.....
munira110 4 years ago 6
Wow Rafi....Rafi... What a commendable job. The control on his voice is god gifted.....His outstanding songs bring tears out of happiness.
simmijames 3 years ago 2