AFI's - 25 Greatest Movie Musicals
Uploader Comments (TheBigValley)
Top Comments
-
singin in the rain as number 1, definitely!
-
*gasp* No Fiddler on the Roof? Anyways, it was a good list. I'm glad West Side Story was high up!!
All Comments (140)
-
aded to this list would be Hairspray (You can't stop the beat, Good morning Baltimore and I know where i've been), Sweeney Todd (Epiphany, WOrst pies in london and No place like London) and Dreamgirls (And i am telling you, One Night Only and It's all over).
-
Oklahoma! was fine, but brutal in some parts. The accents IMO got irritating and the dream sequence was moronic. I agree with keeping it off the list. Glad to see Funny Girl get recognized as Barbara Streisand's best, and especially pleased that Singin' In the Rain is named best movie musical of all time. No movie musical ever got the point of musicals better.
-
my fave five musical movies are: West Side Story (1), RENT (2), Wizard of Oz (3), Hair (4) and Fiddler on the Roof (5).
-
as much as i love MR! BATB and Chicago, imo Oklahoma! Fiddler on the ROof and hair should be on there instead.
-
In my opinion it's a good list. I quite agree with the top three. But , from my point of view "Chicago" it's so overrated!!! I would have chosen instead "Gigi","State Fair(1945)","Camelot","My sister Eieen","Yentl""The fidle on the roof","Golddiggers 1933","Anchors aweigh" ,"High Society"and many more. I love to see on the list: "Top hat" ,"The band wagon" ,"Meet me in St. Louis","My Fair lady","An american in paris","Guys and dolls","Beauty and the Beast"and "Moulin Rouge
-
i don't agree with much here...where is gentlemen prefer blondes??? no way grease or chicago is better than top hat. no broadway melody of 1940, must be 20-30 yr olds making this list. someone needs to go and watch more movies.
-
Wizard of OZ --- awww forever a Timeless Classic
-
Moulin Rouge? Really?
-
the wizard of oz should be #1
-
"Beauty and the Beast" doesn't belong here. It's animated, and to me musicals are mostly about watching live performers sing and dance. I would replace it with "Oklahoma!", which I'm surprised did not make the list.
why is this playing to gone with the wind music?
simolionshane 5 months ago
@simolionshane The theme music from Gone with the Wind, is the same used during the presentation of these films in 2006. I thank you for asking!
TheBigValley 5 months ago
awesome list considering i havent seen about half of these movies!!! the ones i have seen were on the very top, and i LOVED how beauty and the beast made it on. wonderfully done video btw :)
NYCgirl1221 6 months ago
@NYCgirl1221 Thank you so much! Much appreciated!
TheBigValley 6 months ago
but of course singing in the rain is number one!!!!! i knew it right from the beguining!!! :)
alexoldmovies27 6 months ago
@alexoldmovies27 :)
TheBigValley 6 months ago