The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey - Images
Uploader Comments (akihamid1)
Top Comments
-
@TheGidneybean i truly have no idea,i guess haters gotta hate eh?
-
1 DISLIKE FROM SMAUG !!
All Comments (113)
-
peter jackson has lost a lot of waight
-
@siblilngs101 Silmrarion is more a theogony, how the world of middle earth was born
-
@akihamid1 The main problem is that huge parts of it are plain History. The Lord of the Rings is a novel born from that history, much in the same way historic novels take place in our world's history. You can make a movie about say, the French Revolution, but not Europe's entire History.
-
@IchBinUnbesiegt i agree with you, some books and epics are best left to ones imagination, besides from what i hear it sounds more complicated and detailed then the LOTR books
-
@Jbessette But a TV series would be much cheaper and wouldn't do Tolkien justice at all. I guess the Silmarillion is much too complex to be made into a movie. In fact, it's not a novel, but a mythical History of Arda (and even Eä..). It would be like making the Old Testament into a movie or TV series. People should just make an effort and READ books.
-
@siblilngs101 It takes place looong before the LOTR. Thousands of years before, as a matter of fact ;)
-
I hope that they will make a movie on the Silmarillion,too. But it takes place before the LotR. ;) I'ts about the Creation of the World and about the "Silmarillions" which were created by Feanor and stolen by Morgoth.
-
@siblilngs101 I takes place long before LOTR and Hobbit. I think that Silmarilion would be better if it was a TV Series because of the time spectrum in this book(it is chronicle that describes few thousands years of early Middle earth history)
-
@siblilngs101 It's a pre history of Middle Earth, covering the entire first 3 Ages. It's also a bit impractical to make a movie out of it. A lot of that book, except for select sagas, like Beren and Lúthien, are incomplete.
-
it would be better if The Silmarillion were made into a TV series because it is a collection of stories and not just one.
now make a movie on the silmarillion! its also a book by TOLKIEN! though he died before he could finish it his son finished it. tis only proper to make a movie out of that book to! it takes place after LOTR if im not mistaken.
siblilngs101 1 month ago 3
@siblilngs101 yeah iv heard much about that book,iv yet to read it and so many people have ensured me its a good read,il have to get around to it in the summer,but theres enough excitement going around The Hobbit atm;)
akihamid1 1 month ago
2:24 gandalf is stoned haha
ACDC101232 2 months ago 2
@ACDC101232 haha
akihamid1 2 months ago