Genesis - One for the Vine
Top Comments
All Comments (90)
-
@MoonlightKnight94 Don't underestimate Blood on the Rooftops, a great song of English commonness. Not being English myself, it gives me a good look into the mindset of their psyche. Not big on instruments, but still powerful.
-
Me i am 100% with you and my wish: They should wake ob tony from his "Wintersleep" and steve and him and maybe rutherford should make the new genesis-album!
-
If i will want to read a nice meaningful story or some poem, i will probably choose to read some book or watch a movie or sth. Songs like these charted POOR in EVERY chart of every country and ALL of their albums till Duke before Phil got more involved, sold quite miserably. MUSIC is MUSIC. And its NOT to be confused with 'storytelling' and some music on the background. This may be a nice story but still musically and lyrically its boring. And as i said the sales and chart positions prove it.
-
My aunt have that disc in vinyl :D
And Peter was better in Genesis that Phil!
-
@anonymusum if anything, him leaving turned them more pop,
-
True. With Hackett they lost a lot of magic. On the other hand: he wouldn´t have been the right one for the 80s pop.
-
"One for the Vine" is in my top three Genesis songs, just behind "The Musical Box" and "Can Utility and the Coastliners." Sumptuous piece of music.
-
I think Steve Hackett leaving the band was far worse than Peter Gabriel leaving in my opinion. Steve and Tony were my favorite writers in the band, plus i think in 1976 the band never sounded better.
-
3 dislikes?
Everybody fight about who was the better singer peter or phil. Nobody ask how important tony banks was for the band!
btom22259 2 months ago 18
After listening to such a masterpiece like this, it's obvious and evident than Genesis' greatness was not made out of a couple of disguises only...After PG's departure, this wonderful artists kept doing what they knew best: great music for the mind, body and soul...Thanks forever and ever Tony, Mike, Ant, Peter, Chris, Johns ( Silver and Mayhew), Phil, Steve, Darryl, Chester, Bill, Mick, Nir, Nick and Ray...
SoloDrumMusic1969 2 months ago 7