BBC Chronicles of Narnia: LWW - Chapter 5/6 Part 1/3
Uploader Comments (HeathenMaiden)
Top Comments
-
no i disagree i love the disney version of narnia!! so much better.
All Comments (315)
-
Hi, i love the old versions, but remember when i was little watching one version, not cartoon, where in the intro and credits you were flying over green hills, and there was this music i loved... any ideas on which version that was?!
-
So far, after watching both films, I think both are good and bad in different ways, SO STOP TRYING TO COMPARE! Thank you :P
-
Oh me oh my, don't turn this into a disney version of LWW hate. By all means have this has an appreciation society but not to hate on the disney version! Both versions have their pros and cons me thinks. Imo, I think the woman who plays Lucy and Barbara Kellerman (although sometimes OTT) are the only good actors.
-
I love the Witch's dwarf, he sounds like the Chuckle Brothers.
-
"COME TO MEEEEE........ EEEEEHHHEEEEVIIILLLLL..."
-
Epic fight scene with maugrim.
-
I felt sorry for the wolf.
-
@ellezfire22 Actually over all the old cast is good, its just Lucy that brings down this one lol.
-
@HeathenMaiden The script is almost identical with the books and the new movies, Better cast for sure in the new one. I wouldnt say better acting, but the old one is more stage acting than movie acting. Overall. I like both equally lol, nothing beats the original, but the new ones are very well done.
ps...took forever to find this, looked everywhere, thanks for the upload :)
-
That monster that crept along the ground (the one shown after the critter crawling at Edmund's feet) creeps me out, still.
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anyone who says these are better than the new ones is trying WAAAYYYY too hard to hold onto nostalgia. The new ones are much much better. I grew up on these ones, but that doesn't make them superior. It's like saying Bakshi's Lord of the Rings is better than Jackson's.
repka17 9 months ago
@repka17 No, not really. Better how exactly? Better effects? Absolutely. Better cinematography? Sure. Better locations? Some of them. Better sets? Some of them. Better costumes? Some of them. But better script? No. Better cast? No. Better acting? No.
Just because it's better visually doesn't mean it's a better film.
Obviously, this is just my personal opinion. Just like it's your personal opinion that the new ones are better.
HeathenMaiden 9 months ago 25