PRETERITE OR IMPERFECT IN JUST TWO SIMPLE STEPS
Uploader Comments (esaudio)
All Comments (55)
-
@COJW516 He switched the verbs around. Notice one the first one he had "was running" highlighted. The last one he had "fell and broke" highlighted. "Was running" is imperfect and "fell and broke" are preterite.
-
Hey, please reply. I don't understand the last question "is it finished the same moment we are referring to" and I don't understand what does it mean if the action is "finished" or not. Again please reply I have an exam tomorrow!!
-
THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!!!!! I have a test tomorrow and i had NO idea how to do it before i watched your video, now i feel completely understand it! THANKS AGAIN!!!!!!!!! GREAT VIDEO!!!!!
-
Whoa! This helped me out so much!!!! Thank you!
-
thank you so much! i have a spanish test tma on this and this helped me soo much! i had no idea what one to use before but now i get it! hope this helps me on the test! thanks again!
If you want a lengthier explanation, please see me on Facebook at facebook.com SLASH jumpstartyourspanish
esaudio 5 days ago
I'm struggling to get my head around #5. Using your method, what would be put in the diary? When? For how long? Over what period did learning take place?
"It was hard at first but with the help of my teachers.." Day 1 entry: today was hard but my teacher helped me......day 200 entry: today was hard but my teacher helped me [not practical - learning was ongoing, no specific time was stated or implied only "at first" - how long did "at first" last?] so = imperfect? Am I missing something?
ross2503 5 days ago
@ross2503 See it this way... You are speaking NOW, but referring to a period back then.
When you say.. it was hard at first, but with the help of my teachers etc,,,,
You are stating that the first part was already over... Something else happened later. For that reason we use the PRETERITE. You are describing something that is already finished at that point. This is a complex concept even for very advanced students. My suggestion, work with a teacher on this. It will save you a LOT of time!
esaudio 5 days ago
@esaudio Oh yes, doh! Sometimes you just have to step back for a while (or in my case take the dog to the park haha!). Of course, it was hard at first (but that passed/ended and it became easy, you could put into the diary each time you overcame a barrier/something you didn't understand and at each point, that difficulty is now ended - preterite. Thank you for your reply!
ross2503 5 days ago
@ross2503 Great Ross! I am glad you got it! I know it can be a little bit hard to understand the logic at first, but once you do, it will save you lots of headaches! Take care and happy Spanish learning!
esaudio 4 days ago
hi, i have two questions:
Fuimos a la escuela ayer. <--is that preterite??
Yo fui a correr a las tres. <----is that preterite??
bennydong456 3 months ago
@bennydong456 Yes in both cases.
esaudio 3 months ago